Television series
Making a Murderer
A slow-burn true-crime documentary series that spends ten hours making you doubt everything you think you know about Steven Avery's guilt. It's less interested in whodunit than in how a small-town justice system can bend evidence, coerce confessions, and close ranks. Compulsively watchable, genuinely maddening, and the show that arguably kicked off the modern true-crime boom.
If you liked this
Soupçons2004
The blueprint for this whole genre: a French documentarian embeds with a novelist accused of killing his wife, and spends years inside the defense strategy itself. Same slow accumulation of doubt, same discomfort with certainty.
But It's a slower burn, more procedural, less outrage-driven — don't expect the same villain-coded prosecutors.
The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst2015
A real-estate heir, three dead people connected to him, and a documentary crew that gets closer to a confession than anyone thought possible. Tense, meticulously constructed, and ends with one of the most notorious moments in TV history.
But Durst is clearly guilty from early on, so it's less a justice-system indictment than a character study of a monster.
Paradise Lost1996no page yet
The original teenage-outsiders-railroaded-by-a-panicking-town story. Three trilogy films made across 15 years, following the West Memphis Three case as it unravels the state's evidence in real time.
But It's older, grainier, and demands a real time commitment across three feature-length films to get the full arc.
The wildcard
Something you would not have found on your own.
The Thin Blue Line1988
This is the film Making a Murderer's entire grammar descends from — reenactments, ambiguous guilt, a documentary as an act of advocacy rather than just observation.
Errol Morris's stylized, hypnotic documentary about a wrongful murder conviction in Texas literally got an innocent man released from death row — it invented the modern true-crime-doc-as-legal-intervention move decades before Netflix existed.
But The pacing is deliberately hypnotic and the visual style is arty rather than binge-friendly; it asks patience, not adrenaline.
More like this (8)
Amanda Knox2016
A tight, unnerving film about media, gender, and how quickly a foreign suspect becomes a tabloid villain. Knox herself is interviewed, cool and self-aware, which makes the rush-to-judgment feel even more damning.
But At 92 minutes it's a snack next to Making a Murderer's meal — less room to sit with the ambiguity.
The Innocent Man2018
Based on John Grisham's nonfiction book, this follows two Oklahoma men wrongfully convicted in unrelated murders, exposing the same kind of tunnel-vision policing and junk forensic science.
But Splitting focus between two separate cases dilutes the momentum a little compared to a single throughline.
Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist2018
A stranger-than-fiction case — a pizza delivery man dies with a bomb collar and a bank robbery note — that keeps mutating episode to episode. Same small-town-secrets energy, wilder plot.
But It's more concerned with jaw-dropping twists than systemic critique, so the moral weight is lighter.
The Confession Tapes2017
An anthology that does what Making a Murderer did for Avery but across several cases, all hinging on coerced or manipulated confessions. Deeply unsettling on how interrogation rooms work.
But Anthology format means less character depth per case — you get outrage but not the same intimacy.
Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father2008
Starts as a tribute film to a murdered friend and turns into something far more devastating about a broken custody and justice system. Not the same case type, but the same fury at institutional failure.
But This one is genuinely gutting, not just frustrating — go in braced, it earns every bit of its reputation as a heartbreaker.
American Murder: The Family Next Door2020
Told entirely through texts, police footage, and home video with no talking-head interviews, it's a stripped-down, almost unbearably intimate account of a domestic murder case.
But There's no ambiguity here and no justice-system critique — this is about horror, not doubt, so it scratches a different itch.
American Vandal2017
It borrows Making a Murderer's entire documentary toolkit and structural rhythms to build real sympathy for an absurd suspect, exposing just how manipulable the form is.
A pitch-perfect mockumentary about a high schooler accused of spray-painting genitals on faculty cars, shot with the exact tics — slow-mo reenactments, dramatic music stings, earnest narration — of the genre it's spoofing.
But It's comedy, so if you want to stay angry at the justice system rather than laugh at its aesthetics, this will feel like a tonal betrayal.
12 Angry Men1957
Same engine as Making a Murderer — reasonable doubt versus institutional momentum — but staged as a fictional chamber drama instead of a real-world documentary indictment.
A single jury room, twelve men, and a slow dismantling of certainty about a young man's guilt — one of cinema's tightest, smartest studies of how bias, fatigue, and groupthink shape a verdict.
But It's fiction, black-and-white, and confined to one room — no true-crime rush, just pure argument and tension.
People
Production
- Lisa DennisCo-Executive Producer
- Adam Del DeoExecutive Producer
- Laura RicciardiExecutive Producer
- Lisa NishimuraExecutive Producer
- Moira DemosExecutive Producer
Recommended by
The Keepers, The Thin Blue Line, Paradise Lost: The Child Murders at Robin Hood Hills, The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst, Into the Abyss, Amanda Knox, Don't F**k with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer, Casting JonBenet, Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes, The Central Park Five, West of Memphis, Soupçons, The Confession Tapes, Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist, The Innocent Man, Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem and Madness, I'll Be Gone in the Dark, The Pharmacist, How to Fix a Drug Scandal, Murder Among the Mormons, Crime Scene, Evil Genius, Time: The Kalief Browder Story, The Seven Five, The Innocence Files, The Wrong Man, Cape Fear, The Fugitive, 24 Hours in Police Custody, Saman: La verità nascosta, The Passion of Joan of Arc, American Vandal, The Case Against Adnan Syed, The Farm: Angola, USA, The Confession Killer, The Staircase, JAG, Cold Case Files