Film

Abducted in Plain Sight

Name: Abducted in Plain Sight
Genre: Documentary, Crime
Released: 2017
Cast: Jan Broberg Felt, Mary Ann Broberg, Bob Broberg, Susan Broberg, Pete Welsh

This is the true-crime documentary people warn you about before they recommend it. Told almost entirely through the Broberg family's own present-day testimony, it recounts the grooming and abduction of their daughter by a trusted neighbor — and the family's astonishing, repeated complicity. It's for viewers who can tolerate discomfort as the point, not a flaw.

TMDb rating

6.6

If you liked this

The Imposter2012

A documentary about a family who accepts an obvious impostor as their missing son, told with the same queasy fascination with denial and self-deception that makes Abducted so unforgettable.

But The subject is a con man, not a child predator, so the stakes and moral weight land differently.

Three Identical Strangers2018

A jaw-dropping true story with structural twists that recontextualize everything you thought you understood, plus a similar interest in how families absorb the unbelievable.

But It's more of a puzzle-box thriller than a portrait of ongoing manipulation — the horror is intellectual, not visceral.

Capturing the Friedmans2003

Another family caught on camera contradicting itself about abuse, denial, and loyalty — a masterclass in how home footage can indict the people who shot it.

But It's ambiguous by design; you won't get the clean villain or resolution Abducted eventually provides.

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Night of the Hunter1955

Same engine as Abducted decades earlier and in pure fiction: a predator who is likeable enough that the adults responsible for protecting children simply don't.

A black-and-white classic about a preacher who charms his way into a widow's home and her children's lives, radiating menace that every adult around him somehow fails to see.

But It's a stylized studio-era thriller, not a true story, and the pacing is deliberately theatrical rather than naturalistic.

The Keepers2017

A sprawling series about institutional grooming and decades-later reckoning, with the same sense of a community that looked away when it mattered most.

But Seven episodes of unresolved conspiracy is a much bigger commitment than one sitting.

Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father2008

An almost unbearably personal documentary where the filmmaker's closeness to the subject becomes part of the horror — deeply felt in a way few true-crime films risk.

But It's devastating without any of the pulpy propulsion; go in only if you're ready to be wrecked.

Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father poster

Beware the Slenderman2016

Parents blindsided by what was happening to their children right under their noses, plus the same slow dawning horror of realizing you missed everything.

But The internet-mythology angle pulls focus from the family psychology that makes Abducted so compelling.

Athlete A2020

A tightly made documentary about institutional grooming and the adults who enabled it, with the same fury at how obvious the warning signs were in hindsight.

But It's more journalistic and less intimate — there's no equivalent of sitting in a living room with the family.

Shiny Happy People2023no page yet

A family, a charismatic outside authority, and a slow unraveling of what was normalized in the name of trust — familiar emotional terrain in a different setting.

But The religious and cultural specifics of the story are a different flavor of unsettling than Abducted's.

Room2015

A fictional but visceral portrait of captivity and the fallout after escape, carried by extraordinary performances if you want the emotional register without the documentary format.

But It's a drama, not journalism, and the story's shape is entirely different from the Brobergs'.

Flee2021

It's a documentary built on the same idea Abducted leans on hard: some truths only surface once someone finally agrees to say them out loud, on camera, years later.

An animated documentary that uses drawn imagery to tell a real refugee's story of hidden trauma and family secrets he couldn't voice any other way.

But The animation and subject matter — displacement, not domestic abduction — make it feel worlds apart on the surface.

Dirty John2018

Takes the exact same predator-embeds-himself-in-a-family structure and swaps documentary discomfort for soap-opera gloss, showing how differently the same true story can be told.

A glossy, soapy dramatization of a real con man who talks his way into a family and nearly destroys it, with the same slow-motion disbelief at how far denial can stretch.

But It's prestige melodrama with movie stars and a score — the opposite of Abducted's raw, unpolished home-video intimacy.