Film

A Gray State

Name: A Gray State
Genre: Documentary, TV Movie
Released: 2017
Cast: David Crowley, Danny August Mason, Alex E. Jones, Sean Wright, Jason Allen

Conspiracy mystery

A Gray State examines the rise and mysterious death of David Crowley, an Iraq veteran who channeled anti-government ideology into an ambitious dystopian film that magnetized fringe online communities. The documentary traces how charisma, paranoia, and radicalization can spiral into tragedy, asking difficult questions about the line between conviction and delusion without offering easy answers.

TMDb rating

3.3

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you are drawn to documentaries that treat a strange online subculture as a puzzle, and you like tangled first-person accounts from people who were close to an obscure, half-finished project.

Skip it if you want a tidy, fact-checked account with a clear verdict, since this one leans on speculation, fan enthusiasm and open questions rather than settled answers.

What it asks of you: Ninety-three minutes of mostly interviews, with archive clips doing much of the heavy lifting; it moves at a patient, reflective pace and rewards sitting still.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

Tickled2016

A documentary that begins with an eccentric curiosity and descends into genuinely disturbing territory, exploring how communities form around obsession and how normal people can become entangled in something dark.

But The subject matter becomes actively unpleasant, and the filmmakers' own pursuit of truth raises ethical questions that never get fully resolved.

The Toys That Made Us2017

Each episode traces how a cultural artifact reflects the moment it was created and the people who made it, offering the same forensic interest in how ideas take root and spread.

But The tone is celebratory rather than investigative, and it won't scratch the itch for moral ambiguity or real consequences.

Blackfish2013

An investigation into how charismatic individuals operate within systems, and how belief—in a person, a cause, a vision—can override critical thinking among otherwise intelligent followers.

But The narrative becomes polemical, and some of its arguments have been disputed or complicated by later reporting.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from A Gray State

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Act of Killing2012

Both examine how charismatic individuals and communities construct narratives that permit violence, and both force viewers to sit uncomfortably with people who genuinely believe they are right.

A documentary that puts perpetrators of atrocity on screen creating their own narratives, making a film about how ideology justifies violence—confronting both the filmmaker and viewer with complicity and moral vertigo.

But It's extremely disturbing and demands moral courage from the viewer. Some find the filmmakers' methods themselves unethical. It will haunt you.

The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst2015

A true-crime documentary that probes the psychology of a man who may have committed terrible things, with genuine uncertainty about guilt and culpability woven throughout.

But It's a serialized commitment—six episodes—and some viewers find the filmmaking style manipulative in how it withholds and reveals information.

The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst poster

Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief2015

An examination of ideological capture and groupthink, showing how intelligent people become isolated within closed systems that reward certainty and punish doubt.

But It's firmly critical of its subject, so if you're sympathetic to Scientology, the framing will feel hostile rather than investigative.

Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief poster

Abducted in Plain Sight2017

Documents how a family's belief system and isolation made them vulnerable to manipulation and abuse, tracing the gap between perception and reality.

But The subject matter is deeply upsetting, and the film doesn't fully reckon with the ethical dimensions of its own storytelling choices.

Winter Light1963

Both explore what happens when a person's entire worldview—their identity, their purpose—rests on an idea, and what happens when that foundation cracks or is revealed to be hollow.

Bergman's stark meditation on faith, doubt, and the paralysis that comes when certainty collapses. A film about a man's ideological and spiritual crisis, shot with glacial precision and devastating emotional clarity.

But It's slow, abstract, and offers no comfort. If you need plot momentum or resolution, this will feel like punishment rather than cinema.

Possessed1947

Like A Gray State, it documents how isolation, ideology, and mental fragility can intersect, showing lives governed by internal certainties that the outside world doesn't validate—but Possessed never reaches the same tragic terminus.

A Vice documentary series examining people living on the margins of society—abandoned, paranoid, struggling with addiction and mental illness. Raw and unsentimental, it shows lives spiraling without offering diagnosis or redemption.

But It's deliberately unstructured and sometimes feels exploitative. There's no narrative arc, no closure, and no resolution. It can feel gratuitously bleak.