Film
The Loves of Edgar Allan Poe
A 1942 biopic following Edgar Allan Poe through the women who shaped him: his young wife Virginia, his lost love Elmira, and the maternal figures who sustained him. Melodramatic and earnest, shot through with period romance and the gothic sensibility you'd expect. It's gentle biography dressed in studio glamour—more interested in Poe's heart than his mind.
If you liked this
The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex1939
Errol Flynn and Bette Davis in a lavish historical romance about power, passion, and the costs of loving a monarch. Visually sumptuous and dramatically tense in ways that match the emotional intensity here.
But The romance dominates over historical detail, and if you want accuracy over melodrama, you'll find it frustratingly glossy.
Camille1936
Greta Garbo as a woman destroyed by love and circumstance, with the same elegant fatalism that haunts Poe's biography. A masterpiece of romantic tragedy that understands longing as a force that breaks people.
But It's slower than modern film and the emotion is all restraint and glance rather than declaration. Patience required.
The Song of Bernadette1943
Another 1940s biopic with Jennifer Jones as a young woman caught between faith and the world's cruelty. It has the same reverent, intimate approach to a life marked by suffering and transcendence.
But Deeply religious in tone and substance. If faith narratives feel didactic to you, this won't budge that instinct.
Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Loves of Edgar Allan Poe
The wildcard
Something you would not have found on your own.
La Jetée1962
Both use biography and memory as meditation on how love becomes a ghost that shapes everything that comes after.
A 28-minute experimental film told almost entirely in still photographs, about a man haunted by a memory of love across time. It captures what this Poe film reaches for—the way one moment of connection can define and destroy a life.
But It's avant-garde and dreamlike, closer to poetry than narrative. If you need conventional storytelling, this will feel opaque and frustrating.
More like this (8)
A Tale of Two Cities1935
Ronald Colman in Dickens, with the same focus on noble suffering and love that redeems a broken man. Dark, romantic, and genuinely moving about what we sacrifice for those we love.
But The plot is intricate and the pacing can feel plodding if you're not in the mood for classic literature adapted faithfully.
Arrowsmith1931
Ronald Colman again—a biopic of a man devoted to his work and the woman who loves him, caught between ambition and heart. Similar blend of romance and quiet desperation.
But Science and medicine dominate equal time with the love story, which some find dilutes the emotional core.
Viva Zapata!1952
Marlon Brando as a revolutionary haunted by what he's become, with the same tragic inevitability that defines Poe's life. A biopic about a man undone by forces larger than himself.
But It's politically engaged and takes sides in ways that can feel didactic if you just want personal drama.
The Barretts of Wimpole Street1934
Norma Shearer and Fredric March as Elizabeth Barrett and Robert Browning, poets whose love defies her tyrannical father. The same gothic household drama and literary romance.
But Heavily theatrical and confined mostly to interiors, which can feel claustrophobic rather than intimate.
Madame Curie1943
Greer Garson and Pierre Curie navigating genius, marriage, and tragic loss. Another portrait of a brilliant, doomed figure and the woman beside him.
But It smooths the edges of both characters and their relationship. History takes a back seat to emotional beats.
The Magnificent Ambersons1942
Orson Welles' meditation on decay, family, and the impossibility of holding onto what you love. A film about how time and circumstance undo us, which is fundamentally what this Poe story is about.
But It's formally experimental and structurally complex. The narrative doesn't move in straight lines, which frustrates people wanting a clear story.
Synecdoche, New York2008
Both are about artists trying to resurrect the past through their work, and both understand that the archive of love becomes the work itself.
Charlie Kaufman's masterpiece about a theater director creating a replica of life to understand loss and meaning. It's genuinely about Poe's kind of obsession—how art and life collapse into each other, how we build monuments to our dead.
But It's deliberately fragmented and surreal. Most people find it bewildering and exhausting rather than cathartic. Patience and multiple viewings required.
Possession1981
Both are about love as a consuming, destroying force—but where Poe's film romanticizes it, this one shows the horror underneath.
An utterly bizarre Polish-French film where two people's deteriorating marriage and their obsession with each other becomes increasingly Gothic and nightmarish. It captures the darkness of romantic obsession that the Poe film only hints at.
But It's grotesque, sexually explicit, and genuinely disturbing. The performances are operatic and the film is deliberately ugly. Most people find it unbearable or pretentious.
People
Cast
Linda DarnellVirginia Clemm
Shepperd StrudwickEdgar Allan Poe
Virginia GilmoreElmira Royster
Jane DarwellMariah Clemm
Mary HowardFrances Allan
Frank ConroyJohn Allan
Harry MorganEbenezer Burling
Walter KingsfordT.W. White
Morris AnkrumMr. Graham
William BakewellHugh Pleasant
Francis FordTavern Keeper
Mae MarshMrs. Phillips (uncredited)
Directing
- Harry LachmanDirector
Writing
- Samuel HoffensteinWriter
- Tom ReedWriter
Production
- Bryan FoyProducer