Film

The Water Diviner

A post-WWI journey film about an Australian farmer seeking his missing sons across Turkey. Russell Crowe directs and stars in a quietly meditative story about grief, loss, and the possibility of unexpected connection. It's measured and emotional rather than explosive—a film that sits with its characters' pain rather than rushing past it.

TMDb rating3.4

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you want a patient, old-fashioned search story where grief is handled with sincerity and the landscape of a ruined country does half the talking.

Skip it if you find earnest melodrama hard to sit through, since its emotions are big, its pacing unhurried, and its sentiment rarely pulled back.

What it asks of you: Settle in for just under two hours of slow searching, with long stretches of dusty travel and quiet, and a tone that stays mournful rather than brisk.

If you liked this

Gallipoli1981

The foundational Australian war film that established how cinema could honour sacrifice without glorifying combat. Weir's direction is masterful and the friendship at its core resonates decades later.

But Shot on grainy stock and paced by 1980s standards—it requires patience and won't grab you with spectacle.

Gallipoli poster

19172019

A technically audacious single-take war film following soldiers through No Man's Land. Visceral, urgent, and visually stunning—this is modern filmmaking in service of emotional truth.

But Relentless forward momentum can feel exhausting. There's little quiet space to process what you're witnessing.

1917 poster

Come and See1985

Possibly the most devastating war film ever made. A Soviet masterpiece about childhood obliterated by invasion. If you want to understand what modern warfare actually does, this is unflinching testimony.

But Brutal and despairing in ways that go beyond entertainment. Not cathartic—actively difficult to sit through.

Come and See poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Water Diviner

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Ottoman Lieutenant2017

Both films grapple with what Turks and Westerners owe each other after WWI and the Armenian catastrophe, but this one refuses easy answers about morality.

An American nurse and a Turkish officer find love during the Armenian genocide. It's a direct geographic and temporal echo of The Water Diviner's setting, but approaches it from an entirely different angle—focused on impossible connection amid atrocity rather than parental grief.

But Tonally misjudged in places; the romance sometimes overshadows the historical horror. Critics were unkind and for good reason.

The Ottoman Lieutenant poster
More like this (7)

The English Patient1996

Epic, romantic, and formally bold. Multiple timelines weave together a story of love and loyalty against the backdrop of WWII. Swinton, Fiennes, and Binoche are luminous.

But At 2 hours 42 minutes it's an investment, and the fractured narrative takes time to untangle.

The English Patient poster

Paths of Glory1957

Kubrick's searing critique of military hierarchy and the machinery of war. Kirk is magnificent, the cinematography is austere, and it remains shockingly relevant.

But Structured as a courtroom drama rather than action—some find the pacing glacial by modern standards.

Paths of Glory poster

A Farewell to Arms1932

Borzage's romantic tragedy about an American ambulance driver and a British nurse during WWI. Intimate and achingly human, it understands that war destroys the tender as much as the brave.

But Pre-code Hollywood means it looks and sounds nothing like contemporary cinema. Patience required for a different era of filmmaking.

A Farewell to Arms poster

Atonement2007

A layered meditation on guilt, memory, and the stories we tell ourselves. Knightley and McAvoy are heartbreaking, and Wright's direction is formally ingenious across multiple timelines.

But The central reveal reframes everything—some find it manipulative rather than illuminating.

Atonement poster

The Best Years of Our Lives1946

Often overlooked in favour of flashier postwar films, this follows three soldiers readjusting to civilian life. Wyler's direction is warm and the portrait of American resilience is genuinely moving.

But Nearly three hours of domestic adjustment rather than combat drama. Pacing is deliberate and the film trusts silence.

The Best Years of Our Lives poster

In the Land of Blood and Honey2011

Both explore how individuals try to maintain humanity and connection when the machinery of nationalism and military conflict demands they hate each other.

Angelina Jolie's directorial debut about a Bosnian Muslim woman and a Serb soldier during the 1990s war. A love story that won't let you off the hook morally. Formally ambitious and genuinely courageous.

But The historical detail requires homework. It's neither comforting nor traditionally romantic—the war destroys everything it touches.

In the Land of Blood and Honey poster

A Prophet2009

Like The Water Diviner, it's fundamentally about a man navigating a foreign, hostile system and discovering unexpected dignity and alliance in an environment designed to break you.

A French prison drama that's actually a Bildungsroman about a teenage immigrant becoming a man. Masterfully crafted, morally complex, and utterly gripping. Tahar Rahim gives one of cinema's great debut performances.

But It's set in a prison, not a warzone, so the connection isn't obvious. The slow-burn character study won't appeal to those wanting external action.

A Prophet poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by