Film

Day-time Wife

A 1939 screwball comedy where a neglected wife gets her own back by seducing her husband's boss—except nothing goes quite as planned. Tyrone Power and Linda Darnell spark beautifully in a film that trades on mistaken identities, jealousy, and the delicious chaos of people trying to outmaneuver each other. It's breezy, it's sexy in that buttoned-up 1939 way, and it moves.

If you liked this

The Philadelphia Story1940

Made just after this film, it has the same DNA: witty banter, romantic triangles, and elegant people behaving badly in increasingly funny ways. The script crackles. Cary Grant, James Stewart, and Katharine Hepburn are brilliant.

But It's long at 112 minutes, and the tonal whiplash between comedy and sentiment won't land if you're not tuned to the screwball frequency.

The Philadelphia Story poster

Midnight1939

Released the same year, this Wilder-written romantic comedy has the same farcical momentum and sexual tension. Claudette Colbert plays a con artist, and the plot springs forward with genuine wit. Every scene matters.

But The pacing is relentless; if you like your comedies to let you sit with a moment, this won't give you the chance.

Midnight poster

The Awful Truth1937

Cary Grant and Irene Dunne at their peak: a divorcing couple who realize they still love each other, competing over a new romance. It invented this kind of romantic chaos. The dog is funny too.

But Some of the gender politics land strangely now. It's a product of its time in ways that pull you out of the fun.

The Awful Truth poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Day-time Wife

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Trouble in Paradise1932

Both films use romantic deception and workplace seduction as their engine; both feature a woman outmaneuvering a man in business and love. Lubitsch invented the template.

Ernst Lubitsch's masterpiece: a pair of con artists posing as a rich widow and secretary to seduce a perfume magnate. Made seven years before Day-time Wife, it's the ancestor of this film's DNA—smarter, more sophisticated, perfectly made. A revelation.

But It moves in a different rhythm than you're used to; Lubitsch's elegance can read as slow if you're expecting screwball speed. Also, it's genuinely difficult to find in good quality.

Trouble in Paradise poster
More like this (8)

Libeled Lady1936

A tangled plot of seduction, deception, and crossed wires with William Powell, Myrna Loy, Spencer Tracy, and Jean Harlow all perfectly calibrated to each other. The script is a machine.

But It's plot-heavy rather than character-driven, so if you find screwball mechanics exhausting, you'll be exhausted.

Libeled Lady poster

My Favorite Wife1940

Cary Grant again, this time thinking his first wife is dead—until she shows up just as he remarries. The mistaken identities and sexual frustration fuel nonstop comedy that feels genuinely alive.

But It's dependent on a pretty contrived premise. Buy it or don't, but there's no middle ground.

My Favorite Wife poster

The Lady Eve1941

Preston Sturges at his absolute best: Barbara Stanwyck as a con artist who seduces and humiliates an innocent millionaire, then switches tactics entirely. It has heart underneath the schemes, which makes it better than it has any right to be.

But The ending asks you to buy something emotionally that the first two acts spent destroying. Some people find it unsatisfying.

The Lady Eve poster

Ball of Fire1941

A nightclub singer hides in a house full of professors writing an encyclopedia. Howard Hawks directing, Gary Cooper and Barbara Stanwyck sparring brilliantly. It's sexy and funny and made with perfect control.

But The plot is ridiculous even for screwball standards, and the tone can shift without warning between farce and something closer to drama.

Ball of Fire poster

Breakfast at Tiffany's1961

Audrey Hepburn as a woman running scams and reinventing herself, with Henry Mancini's score doing half the emotional work. It's beautiful, funny, and sad in ways that sneak up on you.

But It's slower and more romantic than it is comedic; the laughs serve the mood rather than driving it. Some find it dated or saccharine.

Breakfast at Tiffany's poster

The Thin Man1934

William Powell and Myrna Loy as a married detective couple solving a murder while drinking, flirting, and sniping at each other with perfect timing. It proved that married couples could be sexy and funny in the same scene.

But The mystery plot is genuinely convoluted and almost impossible to follow. You're here for the chemistry, not the whodunit.

The Thin Man poster

Sunset Boulevard1950

Both use seduction and workplace schemes as plot machinery, but Wilder asks: what if this wasn't funny? What if it was desperate? Same skeleton, completely different creature.

Billy Wilder's dark inversion of the Hollywood romance: a beautiful older woman, a desperate young screenwriter, mistaken identities, and sexual manipulation. It has the same surface machinery as Day-time Wife but uses it to excavate desperation and decay instead of create laughs.

But It's a noir, not a comedy. The tone is bleak, the atmosphere is suffocating, and it ends in tragedy. If you want lightness, you'll feel suffocated.

Sunset Boulevard poster

Woman of the Year1942

Both explore marriage as competitive arena and the (flawed) assumption that a woman must trick or seduce to get her husband's attention. But Woman of the Year suggests there's another way.

Katharine Hepburn and Spencer Tracy's first film together: a female political columnist and a male sportswriter in a battle of wills that becomes a love story. It has Day-time Wife's energy but treats its female lead as an intellectual equal, not a schemer getting revenge.

But The ending caves to 1942 politics in ways that will make you angry. After two hours of watching her be brilliant, she's asked to diminish herself for love.

Woman of the Year poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

The Astonished Heart, My Best Girl