Film

Jesse James

Name: Jesse James
Genre: Western
Released: 1939
Cast: Tyrone Power, Henry Fonda, Nancy Kelly, Randolph Scott, Henry Hull

A 1939 Western that romanticizes Jesse James as a wronged man driven to outlawry by railroad corruption. Tyrone Power cuts an dashing figure in this handsome, energetic studio picture—all galloping horses, dramatic shootouts, and moral ambiguity rendered in Technicolor. It's a revenge fantasy dressed up as history, made for audiences who wanted their outlaws sympathetic and their Westerns thrilling.

TMDb rating

3.3

If you liked this

The Outlaw1943

Howard Hughes' scandalous Western, equally interested in mythologizing its outlaw hero and in testing the censors' patience. Baroque, excessive, absolutely committed to its own legend.

But Stops the story dead whenever Jane Russell walks into frame. The politics are queasy. It's a curio as much as a film.

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance1962

Ford's masterpiece about how the West is actually won: by lawyers and newspapers, not gunfire. A Jesse James story told from the other side, with devastating irony about the myths we need.

But Black-and-white, slow, deliberately unglamorous. Less interested in action than in the gap between legend and truth.

Johnny Guitar1954

Nicholas Ray's delirious Western obsessed with performance and desire. Joan Crawford as an outlaw's backer, all cigarettes and command. Genuinely strange and genuinely gripping.

But The plot is a pretext. The dialogue is mannered. Some find it insufferable, others find it perfect—there is no middle ground.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Jesse James

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Johnny Comes Flying Home1946

Both 1940s studio Westerns/dramas about men in crisis, but where Jesse James mythologizes the past, this one reckons with the immediate present and its damaged men.

A musical about shell-shocked veterans struggling to readjust—ostensibly light entertainment, but the wound underneath is real. Same era as Jesse James, same studio machinery, utterly different soul.

But The musical numbers are intrusive. The drama and the songs war with each other. It's schizophrenic by design.

The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford2007

Fincher's long, hypnotic meditation on fame, mythology, and the man behind the legend. Brad Pitt as an aging Jesse, paranoid and exhausted. Takes the outlaw trope and drains it of romance.

But Nearly three and a half hours of men staring at each other. Not remotely thrilling. The pace is funereal and deliberate.

The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford poster

The First Great Train Robbery1978

Crichton's heist film with Sean Connery and Donald Sutherland planning an audacious robbery aboard a moving train. Clever, fun, gorgeously mounted. A righteous theft for once.

But Victorian-era steampunk cosplay. The humor doesn't quite land and the romance feels obligatory.

3:10 to Yuma1957

Delmer Daves' taut Western about a man hired to escort a captured outlaw to a train. All moral pressure and dialogue; one of the finest Westerns ever made about talk and principle.

But Confined, theatrical, almost entirely conversation. Minimal action. Shot in black-and-white and very stark about it.

The Wild Bunch1969

Peckinpah's elegy for the Old West and for violent men who can't adapt. Aging outlaws on one last job. Raw, blood-soaked, and unexpectedly tender. Changes everything about how Westerns could be.

But Graphically violent. Bleak. The politics are complicated and the ending is uncompromising. Not cathartic.

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid1969

Newman and Redford as charming outlaws, clever and funny, always one step ahead until they aren't. Funny, thrilling, and genuinely moving about friendship and mortality.

But Plays fast and loose with history. Sometimes leans too hard on the charm. The tone can feel unmoored.

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid poster

The Ballad of Little Jo1993

Maggie Greenwald's true story of a woman passing as a man in the Old West to survive. Quietly radical, beautifully shot, deeply felt. A genuine revision of the Western itself.

But Very low-key. More elegy than adventure. The historical research sometimes shows; pacing can feel glacial.

The Strange Love of Martha Ivers1946

Like Jesse James, it's a story of childhood violence determining adulthood, but it excavates the psychology rather than mythologizing the crime.

A noir set in the past, gothic and Freudian, with Barbara Stanwyck as a woman built of secrets. Kirk Douglas in his first film, magnetized by Stanwyck. Utterly strange and completely gripping.

But The plot is convoluted. The psychological obsessions are deeply weird. It's a woman's film pretending to be a revenge story.