Film

Manhattan Murder Mystery

Name: Manhattan Murder Mystery
Genre: Comedy, Mystery
Released: 1993
Cast: Woody Allen, Diane Keaton, Jerry Adler, Alan Alda, Anjelica Huston

A Manhattan couple rediscovers their marriage by stumbling into an amateur murder investigation. Allen's neurotic comedy meets genuine mystery plot, with real stakes buried under the wisecracks. It's for people who love the texture of New York, banter that crackles, and characters you'd actually want to know.

TMDb rating

3.6

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you enjoy chatty, neurotic banter and a light whodunit that treats amateur sleuthing as an excuse for squabbling about marriage and the city's social circuit.

Skip it if you want a tightly plotted thriller, since the mystery is a loose pretext for jokes and the clues and suspense come second to the bickering.

What it asks of you: At a brisk 104 minutes, it stays light and chatty, asking you to keep pace with a crowd of side characters and enjoy the rhythm over any reveal.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

Noises Off...1992

A theatrical farce about a play-within-a-play falling apart backstage. Pure ensemble comedy with layered chaos, perfect timing, and the pleasure of watching smart people fumble through increasingly elaborate schemes.

But The humor is very broad and physical—slapstick isn't for everyone, and the pace can feel relentless if you prefer subtlety.

The Thin Man1934

The gold standard for witty couples solving murders together. Myrna Loy and William Powell trade barbs while investigating, with cocktails and chemistry in perfect measure. Pure, elegant fun.

But The pacing and dialogue rhythms are of their era; it moves fast and assumes you're keeping up, which can feel distant on first viewing.

Ghostbusters II1989

New York City, an ensemble cast bickering their way through the absurd, genuine warmth underneath the comedy. Bill Murray's wisecracks land the same way Allen's do—deflating panic with humor.

But The plot is thin and the supernatural elements feel tacked on. It coasts on charm and cast rapport rather than story.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Manhattan Murder Mystery

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

After the Fox1966

Both are mysteries where the fun comes from smart people talking their way through complications. The pleasure is in the con and the banter, not the resolution.

Peter Sellers plays a master criminal posing as a film director making a heist movie as cover. It's a genuine mystery-comedy with multiple layers of performance and scheming, and the dialogue between Sellers and Victor Mature is razor-sharp.

But It's a 1960s Italian-American co-production, which means uneven dubbing and a plot that meanders when it should tighten. The pacing isn't always there.

Dinner and a Movie2001

A couple's evening out spirals into unexpected chaos. The dialogue sparkles, the setups feel lived-in, and there's real affection between the leads even when they're at odds.

But It's a TV movie, which means uneven pacing and moments that feel like they're padding for commercial breaks.

Ruthless People1986

A kidnapping caper where every character is scheming against everyone else. The ensemble cast (Danny DeVito, Bette Midler, Judge Reinhold) makes every scene land, and the twists actually surprise you.

But The tone is broad and occasionally mean-spirited. It punches down as often as it punches at the premise.

A New Leaf1971

Elaine May's misanthropic comedy about a gold digger and a broke aristocrat. The dialogue is sharp, the character work is real, and the ending subverts everything you expected.

But It's obscure for a reason—pacing issues and tonal shifts that can feel off even when they're intentional.

Soap1977

A darkly comic takedown of soap operas with an ensemble cast and genuine serialized plotting underneath the jokes. Chester and Jessica Tate scheme their way through increasingly baroque scenarios.

But The satire is dense and sometimes the show seems unsure whether it's mocking itself or buying in. The first season is messy.

Beetlejuice1988

Tim Burton and Michael Keaton's anarchic ghost comedy. The humor is weirder and wilder than Manhattan Murder Mystery, but it has the same spirit—fun people making chaos look effortless.

But It's much more gothic and stylized. If you want Allen's neurotic New York energy, this swings completely the opposite direction.

The President's Analyst1967

A Cold War paranoia thriller that's actually very funny, with a script that crackles and James Coburn doing deadpan comedy under pressure. It's a spy movie that laughs at itself.

But The satirical targets are dated, and the film tries to do too much—mixing action, romance, and comedy without always landing the balance.

The Lady Eve1941

Both are about couples with marriage trouble stumbling into schemes and deceptions. Both find genuine emotion under the comedy—the laughs matter because we actually care about the relationships.

Preston Sturges' screwball masterpiece about con artists and gullible millionaires. Barbara Stanwyck and Henry Fonda's chemistry is incandescent, the dialogue moves at a sprint, and every scene is a perfectly engineered comic mechanism.

But It's pre-war screwball, which means the worldview is aggressively of its time, and the plot hinges on deceptions that feel cruel by modern standards.