Film

It Started with Eve

Name: It Started with Eve
Genre: Comedy, Romance, Music
Released: 1941
Cast: Deanna Durbin, Charles Laughton, Robert Cummings, Guy Kibbee, Margaret Tallichet

Screwball comedy
Light-hearted

A wartime romantic comedy where a young man recruits a hat-check girl to impersonate his fiancée for his supposedly dying father. When the father recovers, the lie spirals into something neither of them expected. It's a gleaming, buoyant thing—the kind of film that moves like a dance, built on charm and the particular magic of 1940s Hollywood.

TMDb rating

3.6

If you liked this

Breakfast at Tiffany's1961

A woman pretending to be someone she isn't, caught between her real self and her constructed persona, with a man who sees through it. Smart, tender, and funny in exactly the way films used to be.

But It moves at a thoughtful pace that modern audiences sometimes mistake for slowness. And the racial caricature is genuinely hard to watch.

Roman Holiday1953

A princess on the run meets an ordinary man; they fall in love under false pretenses. Audrey Hepburn and Gregory Peck fizz together, and the whole thing is suffused with the melancholy of knowing it can't last.

But The ending requires you to accept a kind of resignation about duty and romance that modern films rarely ask for. Some find it beautiful; others find it sad.

The Philadelphia Story1940

A woman navigating two versions of herself—the person she's expected to be and the person she actually is—with three men, a screwball plot, and a script so smart it glitters. Practically perfect.

But It's a rich person's problem dressed up as universal truth. If you can't enjoy watching the wealthy sort out their feelings, this won't work for you.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from It Started with Eve

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Shop Around the Corner1940

Both use mistaken identity and false pretenses as the engine for genuine feeling, but this one believes romance lives in subtlety rather than spectacle.

Margaret Sullavan and James Stewart as two people who bicker at work while unknowingly falling in love as pen pals. It has the same spirit—deception softening into real connection—but trades broad comedy for aching tenderness. Proof that a Christmas film can be a masterpiece.

But It's quiet and slow-burning in ways that can feel static to modern eyes. The payoff is emotional, not plot-driven.

Singin' in the Rain1952

Pure kinetic joy. A love story wrapped inside a musical about putting on a show, with performances that seem to defy the laws of physics and a script that knows exactly what it is.

But If you're not in the mood for unironic exuberance, it may feel exhausting rather than delightful. Some people need a little more cynicism.

Sabrina1954

A chauffeur's daughter fakes sophistication to win over a wealthy man; the deception unravels into something unexpectedly honest. Audrey Hepburn transforms before your eyes, and the film knows the difference between pretense and growth.

But Bogart can feel stiff in a romantic role if you're not primed to accept him in one. The pacing is elegant but unhurried.

His Girl Friday1940

A rapid-fire romantic comedy where two people who used to be married spar and seduce each other through a newsroom chaos. The dialogue moves so fast you barely breathe, and it's exhilarating.

But The speed and volume never let up; it's exhausting if you're tired. Also made in an era when its attitudes toward women working were progressive for then but dated now.

Meet Me in St. Louis1944

A family musical about change and staying put, built on the chemistry between Judy Garland and the ensemble around her. It's nostalgic without being maudlin, funny without trying too hard.

But It's gentle and domestic in ways that can feel slow if you want plot momentum. The film trusts you to find the drama in ordinary life.

The Major and the Minor1942

Ginger Rogers disguises herself as a twelve-year-old to save money on a train ticket. Yes, really. It's absurd and charming, built on Rogers's impeccable comic timing and the film's willingness to be completely ridiculous.

But The premise is fundamentally weird. Some audiences find it funny; others find it uncomfortable. You have to meet it where it is.

Theodora Goes Wild1936

A small-town woman living a double life—respectable by day, scandalous novelist by night—finds love with a man who admires her secret self. It's witty, sexy for the era, and genuinely fun.

But It's a Pre-Code picture, and the pacing assumes a different kind of viewer patience. If you need clear story beats and modern speed, it may feel thin.

Swing Time1936

The same heart underneath—a lie that becomes truth through proximity and grace—but told primarily through bodies in motion rather than words and situations.

Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers dance their way through a story about deception, reinvention, and falling in love with a version of someone that isn't quite real. The dance sequences are architectural—each one is a conversation. Pure cinema.

But If you don't engage with dance as narrative, you're going to feel like large portions are padding. It also runs 103 minutes on a plot that could fit in 70.

Brief Encounter1945

Both hinge on performance and disguise—maintaining one face while living another—but this explores it as tragedy rather than comedy, asking whether the mask ever comes off.

Two ordinary people have a brief, extraordinary affair sparked by chance. Noël Coward's script moves between their real lives and fantasy, between restraint and passion. It's about what we don't say mattering as much as what we do. Devastating.

But It's very British, very restrained, and it ends the way real life sometimes does: not with triumph but with compromise. You have to be ready for that kind of film.