Television series

The Burning Girls

Name: The Burning Girls
Genre: Drama, Horror, Thriller
Released: 2023
Cast: Samantha Morton, Ruby Stokes, Conrad Khan, Paul Bradley, Janie Dee

Mystery
Very dark

A female vicar and her teenage daughter move to a village built on centuries of blood and secrets. The Burning Girls is tense, atmospheric, and genuinely unsettling—less jump-scare horror than slow-burn dread. It's for people who want their mysteries dark and their communities rotten, who believe small towns have teeth.

TVMaze rating

3.5

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you relish slow-burn village mysteries where a church's bloody past feels like a pressure cooker, and you don't mind a vicar heroine who is also a worried mum.

Skip it if you want a fast, twisty plot with clear answers, because this is a slow, atmospheric build that lingers on dread and the uneasy feeling that everyone is hiding something.

What it asks of you: Six episodes of roughly fifty-two minutes each, so it moves at a patient, unhurried pace and asks you to stay with a mood rather than chase quick scares.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

The Fall2013

Obsidian-dark Belfast thriller where the hunt for a serial killer becomes a psychological duel between hunter and prey. Stella Gibson is terrifying precisely because she's competent. This is bleak cinema on television.

But Relentlessly grim. Not a show that offers comfort or release. Season three loses momentum badly.

MINDHUNTER2017

The invention of criminal profiling, told through meticulous dialogue and moral argument. Slow, intelligent, and built on the idea that understanding evil doesn't make you safe from it.

But Glacial pacing. Long conversations about psychology instead of action. The second season frays badly.

The Outsider2020

Stephen King's small-town horror adapted with real craft: a supernatural murder mystery that trusts atmosphere more than spectacle. Ben Mendelsohn is magnificent.

But Stretches the premise thin by season's end. The monster reveal is less interesting than the investigation itself.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Burning Girls

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Midnight Mass2021

Both are obsessed with small communities where religion and darkness become indistinguishable, where faith itself becomes a kind of haunting.

A priest returns to an island parish where miracles begin happening. It's a vampire story, a faith story, and a meditation on how communities rationalize the irrational. Mike Flanagan at his most precise and devastating.

But The final two episodes are almost pure dialogue and philosophy. Some will find it preachy rather than exploring.

Mare of Easttown2021

A detective buried in a depressed Pennsylvania town solves a murder that mirrors her own grief. Kate Winslet delivering her finest work in six perfect hours. Mystery, character, and landscape collapse into one.

But Slower than its reputation suggests. The finale prioritizes mood and damage over tidy closure.

Picnic at Hanging Rock2018

Dreamlike Australian Gothic: three schoolgirls vanish on a summer outing, and the show explores the psychic aftershock across a whole community. Beautiful, eerie, and genuinely disorienting.

But Ambiguity is the whole point—if you need answers, you'll hate it. Some find it frustratingly slow.

Tin Star2017

A British ex-cop moves to a Canadian oil town and discovers it's built on corruption and violence. Darker and wilder than it has any right to be. Tim Roth is unhinged in the best possible way.

But The plot gets away from itself. Wildly uneven in quality, with some truly baffling choices by the end.

The Sinner2017

Short-run anthology mystery where the question isn't who did it, but why. Each season takes a self-contained crime and excavates the damage underneath. Elegant and humane despite the darkness.

But The first season is far better than what follows. Later seasons feel obligatory rather than necessary.

Yellowjackets2021

Plane crash survivors in the wilderness, haunted decades later by what happened there. Part mystery, part horror, part trauma study. Young casts and flash-forwards keep the momentum alive.

But Deliberately withholding. The show loves mysteries more than solutions. Some plot threads remain unsatisfying.

The Wailing2016

Both treat evil and innocence as mysteries the community can't solve for itself. Both suggest that knowing the truth might not save you.

A South Korean detective investigates murders in a village where a mysterious stranger has arrived. Mystery, horror, and theological argument collide in a fever dream. Handsomely shot, deeply disorienting, unforgettable.

But Genuinely cryptic—it withholds meaning rather than revealing it. You'll argue about what happened for months. The runtime is 156 minutes.

A Dark Song2016

Like The Burning Girls, it uses occult dread as a language for psychological suffering. Both suggest that what haunts us most is memory and guilt, not ghosts.

A woman hires an occultist to perform a dangerous ritual in an abandoned house. Slowly, unbearably, it becomes clear this is really about grief and desperation, not the supernatural. Intimate, strange, and moving in ways horror rarely attempts.

But Nothing happens by conventional standards. It's patient to the point of stillness. The ambiguity about whether anything supernatural occurs will frustrate people who want clarity.