Television series

Sherlock & Daughter

A contemporary Sherlock Holmes joins forces with a young American woman who may be his daughter to solve her mother's murder and untangle a global conspiracy. It's a character-driven mystery thriller that uses the detective formula as scaffolding for a stranger-becomes-family story. For anyone who loves procedurals with emotional weight and the particular thrill of watching a guarded person learn to care.

TVMaze rating3.5

If you liked this

Prodigal Son2019

A brilliant but damaged investigator partners with his forensic psychiatrist father to solve murders. Like Sherlock & Daughter, it fuses the procedural engine with deep character wounds and family revelation that drive every case.

But The tone lurches between campy and genuinely dark, and some viewers find the father-son dynamic exhausting rather than compelling.

Prodigal Son poster

Luther2010

Idris Elba as a detective obsessed beyond reason with his cases. Each season deepens the personal cost of the work. Shares the DNA of a man too smart for comfort, haunted by what he sees.

But Relentlessly bleak and sometimes exploitative with violence. The second half loses some viewers' patience.

Luther poster

Broadchurch2013

A closed-community murder mystery that peels back layer after layer of hidden lives and old betrayals. The investigation is meticulous; the emotional toll is the real story.

But It's slow and suffocating by design. If you need plot momentum over atmosphere, this will frustrate you.

Broadchurch poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Sherlock & Daughter

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Mentalist2008

Both feature a brilliant, emotionally unavailable protagonist who solves cases while slowly being drawn into real human connection—not despite their gifts, but through learning what those gifts cost.

A con-man-turned-investigator uses fake psychic powers and genuine psychology to solve murders. Like Sherlock & Daughter, it's about a skilled loner learning to trust a partner and finding family in an unlikely place.

But It runs seven seasons and the central premise gets repetitive. The final season pivots to romance in ways that derail the procedural appeal.

The Mentalist poster
More like this (8)

Veronica Mars2004

A young detective solves cases in her California town while navigating her own trauma and family secrets. Sharp dialogue, genuine stakes, a protagonist who's both vulnerable and lethal.

But The early seasons are sharper than the later ones. The show sometimes prioritizes romance subplot over investigation logic.

Veronica Mars poster

The Fall2013

Stella Gibson hunts a serial killer across Belfast with surgical intelligence and moral clarity. A two-person chess game where the cat and mouse know each other's moves.

But It's glacially paced and the killer is charismatic in ways some find exploitative. The final season splits opinions badly.

The Fall poster

MINDHUNTER2017

FBI agents pioneering criminal profiling learn to think like killers. Masterfully acted, meticulously researched, obsessed with the psychology of the work and the men doing it.

But It was cancelled on a cliffhanger. Many episodes are talk-heavy procedural with no forward plot momentum.

MINDHUNTER poster

Hannibal2013

A profiler and a cannibal psychiatrist circle each other in a baroque psychological thriller. Visually stunning and deeply weird, with genuine affection between two monsters.

But The plot is glacial, the tone pretentious, and it revels in stylized gore that exhausts some viewers quickly.

Hannibal poster

Unforgotten2015

An older detective reopens cold cases, interviewing suspects and finding unexpected humanity in old wrongs. Methodical, melancholy, interested in how the past haunts us.

But It's a slow burn with British pacing. If you want quick answers and closure, you'll find it digressive.

Unforgotten poster

Fringe2008

A team of investigators probes impossible science crimes that unravel into parallel universes and existential threat. Fun, clever, and genuinely inventive with strong ensemble chemistry.

But The mythology gets convoluted and the show loses focus in later seasons. Some arcs feel abandoned.

Fringe poster

Killjoys2015

Both are fundamentally about found family forming under investigation—characters bonded not by blood but by stakes and the discovery that they need each other.

Bounty hunters in space solve odd jobs that thread into larger conspiracies. It's lighter and weirder than Sherlock & Daughter, but shares the core: mismatched partners becoming family through shared danger and loyalty.

But It's campy and low-budget in ways that undercut tension. If you need grounded realism, the tone is too playful.

Killjoys poster

A Simple Favor2018

Like Sherlock & Daughter, it uses the mystery framework to tell a story about two women discovering their connection through investigation—what you're solving and who you're solving it with are the same question.

A mother and a mysterious stranger team up to investigate the disappearance of the stranger's husband. Stylish, darkly funny, with two women circling around secrets and gradually discovering who they're really solving for.

But The twist is divisive and some feel it betrays the tone. It's slicker than it is deep.

A Simple Favor poster

People

Cast

Writing

Production