Film

The Mistletoe Inn

Name: The Mistletoe Inn
Genre: Drama, TV Movie, Romance
Released: 2017
Cast: Alicia Witt, David Alpay, Casey Manderson, Lucie Guest, Linden Banks

Romantic drama
Light-hearted

A romance novelist licks her wounds at a Vermont writing retreat before Christmas, where she's paired with an irritating stranger and unexpectedly finds both her voice and her heart. Hallmark-adjacent comfort viewing: soft-focus, predictable, earnest about second chances. For people who want to believe in the redemptive power of a cosy inn and a meet-cute.

TMDb rating

3.0

If you liked this

The Holiday2006

Two women swap homes for Christmas and discover themselves through new romance and old friendship. Nancy Meyers at her most luxurious and wise—funny, smart, gorgeously shot, and genuinely moving about female autonomy and healing.

But Nearly two-and-a-half hours of melodrama with a Jude Law subplot that hasn't aged brilliantly. Also very expensive-looking in ways that can feel alienating.

Under the Tuscan Sun2003

A woman impulsively buys a villa in Italy after her divorce and slowly rebuilds herself through writing, new friendships, and unexpected love. Lush, optimistic, and genuinely about starting over rather than just finding a man.

But The plot is slight and the growth feels more like wish-fulfilment than earned change. Some find it saccharine.

About a Boy2002

Cynical bachelor meets idealistic single mother and her son; all three transform each other. Warm, funny, real about loneliness, and surprisingly moving. A film that likes all its people.

But The tone shifts can feel uneven. Some of the comedy lands differently now than it did two decades ago.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Mistletoe Inn

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Rosie Project

Both are about people who think they know what they want in a story, then have their assumptions upended by an unexpected partner. Both prize writing as a form of self-discovery.

A socially awkward genetics professor creates a questionnaire to find the perfect partner, then meets a woman who breaks every criterion—and his carefully ordered life. Based on a novel by Graeme Simsion, it's genuinely funny about loneliness and rigidity. Chemistry emerges from incompatibility.

But The film is Australian and low-budget, which means it lacks Hollywood polish. The premise risks feeling reductive about neurodiversity.

Practical Magic1998

Two sisters break a family curse with the help of romance and sisterhood. A witchy fairy tale that's genuinely romantic without being saccharine, funny, and aesthetically gorgeous. Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman have real chemistry.

But The plot occasionally takes a tonal lurch into darkness. It's not quite supernatural romance and not quite thriller, which can feel indecisive.

You've Got Mail1998

Two business rivals are unknowingly pen pals falling in love online. Nora Ephron at her peak: witty, romantic, deeply about New York, books, and the gap between who we think we are and who we are. Endlessly rewatchable.

But Dated in its depiction of big business crushing small bookshops (and winning). The romance resolves its central conflict in ways that feel unearned if you think about it hard.

Outlander2014

A 1940s woman falls through time and falls for a Highlander in 18th-century Scotland. Ambitious historical romance with real stakes, gorgeous cinematography, and central chemistry that carries entire episodes. Genuinely addictive.

But It runs to eight hours per season and not every subplot justifies its length. The constant trauma and separation can feel like emotional manipulation rather than drama.

When Calls the Heart2013

A young teacher moves to a prairie town and builds a life, community, and romance. Wholesome without being naive, with a genuine ensemble that grows richer each season. For people who like character over plot.

But The production values are TV-movie modest. The pace is deliberately slow in ways that can feel static if you're looking for conventional narrative momentum.

Jane Eyre2011

Mia Wasikowska as the independent, principled orphan who falls for a complicated man in a gothic mansion. More atmospheric and psychologically complex than other adaptations. Visually stunning and genuinely unsettling.

But The gothic melodrama won't be for everyone. It's quite dark and some of the visual choices are genuinely eerie rather than romantic.

Autumn in New York2000

A May-December romance between an older restaurateur and a younger woman unfolds against the autumn city. Richard Gere and Winona Ryder have real chemistry. It's about longing, temporality, and the romance of NYC in fall.

But The age gap is uncomfortable and never fully addressed as such. The ending is bleak in ways that undercut the romance rather than deepen it.

The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Pie Society2018

A writer on retreat finding herself through the writing process and through people who challenge her assumptions. Both films believe in the redemptive power of being vulnerable with strangers.

A post-war novelist travels to the Channel Islands to research a book and finds community, healing, and love among the islanders who survived the occupation. Intelligent romance that prioritises emotional truth over plot mechanics. Beautifully shot and genuinely moving.

But It's a very quiet film that depends entirely on you caring about slow-burn character connection. There's almost no conventional drama.

The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Pie Society poster

Sylvia2003

Both centre on women writers fighting for recognition and autonomy. Sylvia is the mirror image of The Mistletoe Inn's comfort—it shows what happens when a woman writer's story isn't allowed to be a romance, and what she loses.

Gwyneth Paltrow as Sylvia Plath during her marriage to Ted Hughes and her spiral toward suicide. Not a romance, but a portrait of artistic ambition, mental illness, and a woman's need to be seen as a writer, not just a wife. Visceral and unsparing about what brilliance can cost.

But It's bleak and offers no uplift or catharsis. The subject matter is suicide and depression. This is a film about the cost of silencing a voice, not the joy of finding one.