Film

She Loves Me

Name: She Loves Me
Genre: Romance, Music, Comedy
Released: 2016
Cast: Laura Benanti, Zachary Levi, Jane Krakowski, Gavin Creel, Byron Jennings

A film of the beloved Sondheim musical about two bickering perfume shop clerks who unknowingly fall in love through anonymous letters. Tender and funny, with music that glows. It's a love letter to longing, misunderstanding, and the small grace of being truly known. For anyone who believes in the transformative power of a really good song.

If you liked this

Singin' in the Rain1952

Pure joy distilled into 103 minutes. The dancing is virtuosic, the story is charming, and it captures that exact feeling of euphoria that She Loves Me reaches for—when the world becomes a stage for your happiness.

But It's a Hollywood musical from another era, which means the gender dynamics can feel quaint. The plot is thin as tissue.

Amélie2001

A whimsical romance about connection and small kindnesses, shot with painterly beauty. Like She Loves Me, it finds magic in the everyday and celebrates the joy of making someone else's life better through subterfuge.

But The quirk can feel precious. If you don't buy into that particular Parisian fantasy, nothing will land.

The Philadelphia Story1940

Sparkling dialogue, a woman who's prickly on the outside, a man who sees past it, and the chemistry to make you believe in all of it. The wit is sharp without ever turning cruel. Impeccably made.

But The class politics are very 1940, and not in a good way. Some of the bits feel dated.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from She Loves Me

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Umbrellas of Cherbourg1964

Both are musicals about people trying to find each other across small misunderstandings, but Cherbourg is genuinely tragic where She Loves Me is hopeful—a dark mirror version of the same longing.

A musical so gorgeous it almost doesn't matter that it's in French—the colors alone tell the story. Two young people circling each other across seasons, missing and not quite missing each other. It has She Loves Me's ache for connection, but with a sadness that Sondheim never reaches for.

But The pastel aesthetic is all-consuming; if that world doesn't pull you in immediately, you're watching from outside. It requires patience with its own beauty.

Breakfast at Tiffany's1961

Audrey Hepburn at peak charisma, a tender love story, and New York City transformed into a dream. The film understands loneliness the way She Loves Me does, and offers connection as its answer.

But Henry Mancini's score, beloved as it is, can overshadow everything else. The ending has problems.

Guys and Dolls1955

Another musical about people pretending not to fall in love while falling in love. The songs are tremendous, the cast is committed, and it has that same mixture of sentiment and humor She Loves Me nails.

But Marlon Brando singing is... an acquired taste. The pacing drags in the second half.

It Happened One Night1934

The template for romantic comedy. Two people who think they hate each other, forced together, banter their way to love. It's economical, smart, and the chemistry is absolutely real.

But The screwball pace can feel exhausting if you're not in the mood. The print quality varies wildly.

Sabrina1954

Hepburn again, but this time as the overlooked girl who blooms into her own power. A quieter romance that understands the tenderness of watching someone become themselves.

But It's very much a product of its time—the wealth is unexamined, the morality is easy. Some scenes feel draggy now.

Funny Girl1968

Barbra Streisand's debut, and it's a showstopper. A woman who's funny and complicated, loved for being herself. The songs are anthems, the scale is grand, and it's utterly alive.

But The second half loses momentum. The romance is less interesting than Fanny herself, which the film doesn't quite acknowledge.

The Music Man1962

A con man and a librarian, the power of music to transform a town, and a romance built on seeing through each other's masks. It's wholesome without being saccharine, earnest without being naive.

But The score has some deeply uncomfortable racial content. The length is brutal, and some numbers feel like they're stopping the story dead.

Carol2015

Both films believe that love begins in seeing and being seen; both understand that knowing someone through words (letters, conversations, glances) is more intimate than physical proximity. Both are about people learning to recognize themselves in another person.

A love story between two women in 1950s America, shot with the same tender attention to glances and moments that She Loves Me brings to its letter-writing scenes. It's quiet, achingly beautiful, and builds toward something true.

But It's a period piece about forbidden love, which means there's real sadness baked in. The pace is glacial—things happen in looks, not actions.

In the Mood for Love2000

Like She Loves Me, this is about two people learning to love each other through proximity and subtlety rather than declaration. Both understand that the most romantic moment is when someone finally knows what you've been feeling all along. Both films argue that restraint is its own form of passion.

Wong Kar-wai's masterpiece about two neighbors who discover their spouses are having an affair and begin to fall in love without ever saying so. Pure cinema, pure longing, pure music (the soundtrack is a character). It's the most beautiful film about desire ever made.

But Nothing happens. It's entirely composed of glances, silences, and the space between people. If you need plot, you'll feel like you're watching paint dry in slow motion.