Film

Rogues of Sherwood Forest

A 1950 Technicolor swashbuckler where Robin Hood's son inherits the family business of robbing from the rich. It's bright, breezy, and earnest about its adventure—the kind of Saturday matinee picture that takes itself seriously enough to be fun but never so seriously that it forgets to entertain. For anyone who loves costume action without irony.

If you liked this

The Adventures of Robin Hood1938

Errol Flynn in Technicolor doing exactly what Rogues aspires to: pure swashbuckling joy with sword fights, charm, and genuine visual invention. A masterclass in adventure filmmaking.

But Nearly three hours long, and the Technicolor can feel garish to modern eyes. Some of the comedy moments haven't aged perfectly.

The Adventures of Robin Hood poster

Ivanhoe1952

Robert Taylor in another Technicolor medieval adventure from around the same era. Similar DNA—action, romance, clear heroes and villains—but with a bigger budget and more elaborate set pieces.

But It's ponderous in places and the love triangle feels obligatory. Not as swiftly entertaining as it should be.

Ivanhoe poster

The Black Pirate1926

Douglas Fairbanks doing what Rogues does but earlier and with more acrobatic verve. A silent-era adventure that moves like quicksilver and proves the template works without sound.

But It's silent, which means no actors can carry scenes on dialogue alone. Some action beats are hard to parse in black and white.

The Black Pirate poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Rogues of Sherwood Forest

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Story of Robin Hood and His Merrie Men1952

Both 1950s Technicolor adventure films where a Robin Hood legend gets told again from scratch, competing for the same audience in the same year, each making completely different artistic choices.

Disney's answer to the swashbuckler, made in Britain with real English locations and an almost storybook sensibility. Richard Todd as Robin, Errol Flynn as a villain—technically a different Robin Hood film but made in the exact same moment as Rogues, with comparable budget and spirit but a radically different approach.

But It's aimed at families and has none of Rogues' rough edges. The wholesomeness might feel cloying to adult viewers wanting more grit.

The Story of Robin Hood and His Merrie Men poster
More like this (7)

Captain Blood1935

Errol Flynn's first major role, a pirate adventure with the same swash-and-buckle energy as Rogues but more urgency. Beautifully shot and genuinely thrilling.

But Older production values and a slower first act. The romance subplot, while charming, sits uneasily alongside the action.

Captain Blood poster

The Mark of Zorro1940

Tyrone Power as a masked avenger with the same spiritual mission as Robin Hood—fighting tyranny through wit and swordplay. The template that inspired everything else on this list.

But It's in black and white and feels theatrical compared to later adventures. The pacing drags in the middle act.

The Mark of Zorro poster

The Prince of Thieves1948

Jon Hall as the son of a thief, almost a spiritual sibling to Rogues. Lesser-known than the others but earnest in the same way, with decent action and a lighter touch.

But It's genuinely obscure and sometimes hard to find. The production values are noticeably cheaper, which shows in the fights.

The Prince of Thieves poster

Scaramouche1952

Stewart Granger in Technicolor playing a man who trains to be a swordsman to avenge injustice. Similar spirit—personal stakes wrapped in adventure, with real fencing skill on display.

But The plot takes a while to move into high gear. Some of the dialogue is overwrought even by 1950s standards.

Scaramouche poster

The Black Shield of Falworth1954

Tony Curtis in medieval adventure mode, all charm and swordplay. Another Technicolor romp from the same era that never mistakes itself for Shakespeare.

But It's very silly and doesn't hide it. The script is pretty thin and relies almost entirely on Curtis's charisma.

The Black Shield of Falworth poster

The Crimson Pirate1952

Burt Lancaster being acrobatically joyful in a pirate adventure with real stunt work and gleeful energy. It finds humor without winking at the audience.

But It's cartoonishly broad in tone. Some viewers want their adventures played straight, and this one never stops grinning.

The Crimson Pirate poster

The Man in the Iron Mask1939

Inherited legacy narrative—like Rogues' son carrying on his father's name, this is about a masked hero protecting someone else's legacy—but executed with the weight of a prestige picture rather than a swashbuckler.

James Cagney as D'Artagnan in a Dumas adaptation with genuine emotional weight beneath the adventure. It finds real stakes in costume adventure without losing the fun—shows what the form can do.

But It's over two hours and takes itself seriously, which means it moves slower than Rogues. The dialogue can be purple.

The Man in the Iron Mask poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Recommended by

The Story of Robin Hood and His Merrie Men