Film

Merry Go Round of 1938

A pre-war screwball comedy where Bert Lahr and Jimmy Savo play a pair of lovable lunatics loose in Hollywood, manufacturing chaos at every turn. It's a breezy, music-filled romp built on slapstick, wisecracks, and the kind of anarchic energy that defined Depression-era entertainment. Perfect if you want to see Lahr doing his thing before he became famous.

If you liked this

It's a Gift1934

W.C. Fields at his misanthropic best, battling family, store customers, and his own incompetence with withering contempt. A masterclass in timing and the art of playing a man perpetually wronged by existence.

But Fields' comedy is aggressively cranky and mean-spirited; if you prefer likeable protagonists, he'll wear on you quickly.

It's a Gift poster

Sons of the Desert1933

Laurel and Hardy at their sweetest and funniest, playing best friends who devise an elaborate lie to sneak away. The plot is thin; the warmth, timing, and genuine affection between them is everything.

But Their appeal is completely dependent on silent and sound gag technique. If slapstick leaves you cold, nothing here will change your mind.

Sons of the Desert poster

Swing Time1936

Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers in a romantic comedy that matters primarily because of the dance sequences—jaw-dropping, inventive, and joyous. The story exists to frame the music.

But The plot is gossamer-thin and occasionally cringe by modern standards. You're really just here for the dancing.

Swing Time poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Merry Go Round of 1938

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Singin' in the Rain1952

Both films are love letters to the entertainment industry from within it—the chaos comes from people who simply cannot stop performing and scheming.

Gene Kelly and Donald O'Connor in a film that's ostensibly about the transition to sound in Hollywood. It captures the same screwball spirit and love of performance as Merry Go Round, but with ten years of technical sophistication.

But It's glossier and more polished than 1938 Hollywood; if you prefer the rough grain of earlier comedy, this will feel like a later echo.

Singin' in the Rain poster
More like this (8)

The Thin Man1934

William Powell and Myrna Loy as a witty, boozy, genuinely affectionate married couple solving murders while flirting with each other. It's a mystery that succeeds because you want to spend time with them.

But The mystery itself is labyrinthine and not especially satisfying; the charm depends entirely on chemistry.

The Thin Man poster

Twentieth Century1934

John Barrymore and Carole Lombard as a manic Broadway impresario and his protégée, locked on a train together. Reckless, frantic energy—everyone performs as though the theater is the only thing that matters.

But The pacing is relentless and exhausting; the hysteria never lets up, which some will find exhilarating and others will find shrill.

Twentieth Century poster

Libeled Lady1936

Spencer Tracy, Jean Harlow, William Powell, and Myrna Loy in a newspaper comedy of errors. Pure craft: the script is airtight, the ensemble timing is immaculate, and nobody puts a foot wrong.

But It's efficient to the point of being streamlined—no room for character development, just plot spinning. If you need emotional depth, look elsewhere.

Libeled Lady poster

My Man Godfrey1936

William Powell as a homeless man hired by a scatterbrained heiress (Carole Lombard), turning the film into a Depression-era fairy tale with genuine satirical teeth about class and worth.

But Beneath the comedy is a softer heart than its era's typical cynicism; some will find that sweetness undermines the social critique.

My Man Godfrey poster

The Music Man1962

Robert Preston reprising his Broadway role as a charismatic con artist in a small Iowa town. It's a musical that's genuinely about performance and persuasion, with a score that hasn't aged a day.

But It's wholesome to the point of saccharine, and if you find that particular flavor of Americana cloying, the film won't surprise you.

The Music Man poster

Lucky Stars1935

A lesser-known comic ensemble piece with strong bits and supporting performances. A solid evening if you want screwball adjacent entertainment without the household names.

But It feels like a curiosity now—likeable but forgettable, easier to appreciate than to actually remember.

Lucky Stars poster

Mon Oncle1958

Like the pre-war comedies, Tati builds laughter from character and situation rather than gags or one-liners. Both films love people who simply cannot fit neatly into the world.

Jacques Tati in color, playing his character Monsieur Hulot navigating a perfectly modern, hideously over-designed world. Comedy born from the collision between human messiness and imposed order.

But There's minimal dialogue and no plot arc; it's a series of sight gags and the appreciation of physical comedy in space. Patience required.

Mon Oncle poster

It Happened Here1966

Both films are built on the idea of ordinary people causing mischief through their own nature. Here, the mischief has weight—a 1930s screwball sensibility applied to history itself.

A mockumentary filmed in occupied Britain during an alternate WWII. The tone oscillates wildly—horrifying, absurd, intimate, grotesque—built on the idea that people muddle through even under impossible circumstances.

But It's intentionally tonal whiplash and deeply uncomfortable. The comedy and the horror don't resolve; they sit uneasily together. Not for anyone seeking tonal coherence.

It Happened Here poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

High, Wide and Handsome