Film

Incident at Loch Ness

Name: Incident at Loch Ness
Genre: Comedy, Adventure, Horror
Released: 2004
Cast: Werner Herzog, Zak Penn, Kitana Baker, Gabriel Beristain, Russell Williams II

Supernatural mystery

Werner Herzog and filmmaker Zak Penn travel to Scotland to document the Loch Ness Monster, only to find their expedition falling apart in increasingly absurd ways. Part mockumentary, part creature feature, it's a playful riff on cryptid obsession and filmmaking chaos—best appreciated by those who find Herzog's deadpan intensity and production disasters amusing rather than frustrating.

TMDb rating

2.9

If you liked this

This Is Spinal Tap1984

The gold standard for affectionate mockumentaries about people taking themselves seriously in ridiculous circumstances. Perfect template for understanding Incident's approach to documentary comedy and its deadpan humor.

But It's essentially a one-note joke stretched to feature length. If that note doesn't make you laugh immediately, ninety minutes is a long time.

Ghostbusters1984

Balances comedy with genuine B-movie creature-feature energy. Shows how to make audience investment in the supernatural feel real even when everything is absurd and escalating.

But It's far more polished and confident than Incident. If you're seeking that same tone, the difference might disappoint.

The Comeback2005

Lisa Kudrow's mockumentary about a washed-up actress playing an oblivious version of herself. Shares that uncomfortable, cringe-comedy energy where disaster emerges from ego and delusion.

But The humor is painfully secondhand sometimes. You have to be comfortable with embarrassment as entertainment.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Incident at Loch Ness

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

F for Fake1973

Both are films about filmmaking itself becoming the subject. They ask whether what you're watching is documentary or fiction, and whether that distinction means anything. Welles does it seriously; Incident does it comedically. Both arrive at the same vertigo.

Orson Welles' essay-film about forgery, fraud, and whether anything in media is real. The ultimate meditation on truth versus narrative, documentary versus fiction—everything Incident jokes about, Welles treats as philosophy.

But It's cryptic, formally experimental, and demands active engagement. If you want straightforward entertainment, this is densely layered and elusive.

Waiting for "Superman"2010

Documentary about a serious subject that reveals human obsession, denial, and the gap between narrative and reality. Different tone, similar anatomy of people chasing impossible things.

But It's earnest where Incident is comedic. The register shift might feel jarring if you want to stay in mockumentary land.

Bad Lieutenant1992

Chaotic, unpredictable filmmaking about someone spiraling. Stars Harvey Keitel delivering performances that feel genuinely unhinged rather than controlled, matching Incident's sense that nothing is under control.

But It's grim, violent, and sexual in ways Incident avoids. The tone is genuinely disturbing rather than playful.

The Death of "Superman Lives": What Happened?2015

Documentary about a film that never happened, exploring how creative vision collapses under pressure. Shares DNA with Incident's interest in filmmaking dreams meeting reality.

But It's a documentary about documentaries. If you want narrative comedy rather than behind-the-scenes analysis, this won't scratch that itch.

The Death of "Superman Lives": What Happened? poster

Lake Placid1999

B-movie creature feature with knowing humor and a strong cast having fun with an absurd premise. Same genre-pastiche energy applied to a giant crocodile instead of Nessie.

But It's more conventionally entertaining and less interested in mockumentary awkwardness. Plays it straighter than Incident does.

The Cabin in the Woods2012

Deconstructs horror conventions while remaining a genuine thriller. Shows how to be clever about genre without sacrificing stakes or pace.

But It's far slicker and more confident. If you like Incident's fumbling, chaotic energy, this movie's control might feel cold.

Quest for Fire1981

A genuinely odd adventure film about prehistoric humans searching for fire. Period-appropriate to Herzog's interests; demonstrates how much weird cinema was made in the 1980s.

But It's slow, largely wordless, and very serious about its strangeness. Nothing like Incident's comedy, despite both being strange.

An American Haunting2005

Both chase legends no one can prove. Where Incident finds comedy in obsession, An American Haunting finds dread in the possibility someone was right all along. Inverse tones, identical structural conceit.

Obscure paranormal mystery film that treats a 19th-century poltergeist legend with complete seriousness while remaining genuinely unsettling. Cryptid cinema from the opposite angle: what if the monster was real and horrifying?

But It's dreary and slow, with a twist ending that feels cheap. The seriousness makes it boring rather than funny or scary.

Timecrimes2007

Both feature protagonists drawn deeper into a mystery that might not exist as they imagine it. Herzog/Penn and the protagonist of Time Crimes are both trapped by their own need to understand something that resists understanding. One is funny; one is dark. Same narrative trap.

Spanish sci-fi thriller where a man's investigation of mysterious events reveals he's trapped in a loop of his own making. Relentlessly clever but grounded—a genre film disguised as a mystery about a man's delusion.

But Subtitled, and the twist requires attention to detail. If you're not in the mood to track cause and effect, it becomes frustrating rather than satisfying.