Film

Faithful

A Manhattan housewife on the edge of suicide gets an unexpected reprieve when a contract killer shows up at her door—and somehow they become each other's lifeline. It's a dark comedy that treats depression seriously while mining surprising tenderness from its premise. For viewers drawn to offbeat character studies with bite.

TMDb rating2.8

If you liked this

Barfi!2012

A romance between misfits—one deaf and mute, one struggling with depression—told with visual flair and genuine warmth. Like Faithful, it finds humor and humanity in unlikely places without ever winking at pain.

But It's a Bollywood film running nearly three hours. The tonal shifts between comedy and tragedy take adjustment if you're not expecting them.

Barfi! poster

Punch-Drunk Love2002

Adam Sandler plays against type as a lonely, volatile man who finds connection through unexpected circumstances. Paul Thomas Anderson brings real tenderness to romance between broken people, matching Faithful's strange alchemy.

But It's abrasive and occasionally ugly in its depiction of anxiety. The romance might feel too fragile or awkward depending on your mood.

Punch-Drunk Love poster

Leaving Las Vegas1995

Nicolas Cage and Elisabeth Shue as two damaged people finding companionship in addiction and self-destruction. It shares Faithful's refusal to look away from depression, but with darker stakes and fiercer passion.

But It's relentlessly bleak and contains explicit content. This isn't cathartic—it's a slow, specific kind of drowning.

Leaving Las Vegas poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Faithful

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Synecdoche, New York2008

Both ask whether connection is possible between broken people, and both find the answer in the attempt itself, not in resolution. Faithful is the warm version; this is the nightmare version.

A theater director's life collapses into recursive fiction where art and depression become indistinguishable. Like Faithful, it takes mental illness seriously while staying formally inventive. A film about a man falling apart that is itself fractured and searching.

But It's deliberately confusing and emotionally suffocating. Three hours with no clear plot or ending. Most people find it either brilliant or unbearable.

Synecdoche, New York poster
More like this (8)

Crazy, Stupid, Love.2011

Ensemble comedy-drama about infidelity and marriage that respects both the pain and the absurdity. Tonal control lets it move between laugh-out-loud moments and real emotional weight, much like Faithful attempts.

But It tilts toward crowd-pleasing sentiment in the final act. Some find it too neat for a film about messy relationships.

Crazy, Stupid, Love. poster

Chasing Amy1997

Kevin Smith's take on desire, identity, and the gap between who we want people to be and who they are. Character-driven, unexpectedly sincere, and unafraid to let conversations matter more than plot mechanics.

But The dialogue is talky in ways that feel very '90s indie now. Smith's gender politics, even in a film trying hard, haven't aged perfectly.

Chasing Amy poster

Withnail & I1987

Two broke, depressed men stumble through a vacation in rural England. The humor comes entirely from character and observation; it's genuinely sad underneath the laughs, with a similar dark-comedy rhythm.

But It moves slowly and has almost no plot. British comedy from the '80s—if that sounds tedious, it will be.

Withnail & I poster

After Hours1985

Martin Scorsese's oddball New York nightmare-comedy about a man's night spiraling into chaos. Surreal, funny, and unsettling in equal measure; the city itself becomes a hostile character.

But It's relentlessly strange and occasionally cruel. There's no comfort here, just an escalating sense of dread disguised as comedy.

After Hours poster

Raising Arizona1987

The Coen Brothers' debut finds warmth and humor in characters who are criminals, misfits, and deeply flawed. Visually inventive and tonal in ways mainstream comedies weren't—it earns both its laughs and its heart.

But The pacing and sensibility are deliberately odd. It won't feel like a normal comedy, which is either the point or a dealbreaker.

Raising Arizona poster

The Fisher King1991

Terry Gilliam's film about grief and madness, where a homeless man and a suicidal radio host save each other through connection. Visually wild, emotionally raw, unashamed about the sacred in the broken.

But Gilliam's maximalist style can feel self-indulgent. The tonal shifts are severe—from slapstick to tragedy in a single scene.

The Fisher King poster

A Prophet2009

Both feature hired violence arriving at a doorway and changing everything. Both use an outsider (the killer, the new prisoner) to force their protagonist toward honesty. Both understand that crisis is sometimes the only opening to truth.

A young man enters prison and emerges transformed—a survival story told with novelistic depth and genuine surprise. Character study that could've been thriller-generic but instead digs into loyalty, violence, and becoming someone else.

But It's French, subtitled, and primarily set in prison. If institutional crime drama sounds grim, it is—beautifully, but uncompromisingly.

A Prophet poster

The Safety of Objects2002

Like Faithful, it takes depression and infidelity as the real subject and resists easy sentiment. Both films believe that ordinary unhappiness is worth sustained attention. Both are built from small, true scenes rather than plot events.

Interconnected stories of suburban ennui and hidden damage: affairs, addiction, class anxiety, parenthood. Shot with clarity and observation, it finds the specific sadness in American comfort. Ensemble structure lets every small moment matter.

But It's deliberately undramatic. Things don't resolve; people just continue. The pace is patient to the point of slowness.

The Safety of Objects poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

A Summer Story, The Kreutzer Sonata, A Woman's Decision