Television series
Toy Hunter
- Treasure hunt
- Light-hearted
Toy Hunter follows Jordan Hembrough as he travels the world hunting rare vintage collectibles—toys, comics, memorabilia—to source and flip at Comic Con and other markets. It's a fast-paced treasure hunt show with genuine enthusiasm for pop culture history, appealing to collectors, nostalgia seekers, and anyone who loves the thrill of a good find.
If you liked this
Antiques Roadshow1979
The gold standard of appraisal television. Experts authenticate and value items people bring in, with real surprises and generous deep dives into collecting history and craftsmanship across all categories.
But Episodes are long and contemplative; the pace is glacial compared to modern reality TV, which some find tedious.
Pawn Stars2009
Fast-moving hunt-and-negotiate energy set in a Vegas pawn shop. The Harrisons evaluate pop culture, toys, and memorabilia constantly, with genuine expertise and character-driven friction that keeps it entertaining.
But The formula gets repetitive—every item hits the same negotiation beats—and the theatrical drama can feel manufactured after a few seasons.
Storage Wars2010
The thrill of blind bidding on storage units full of mystery goods, with sharp personalities and real stakes. Watching collectors spot treasures in junk is genuinely satisfying and fast-paced.
But Often staged or exaggerated; the drama between cast members overshadows the actual finds, and winners' profits are rarely as tidy as suggested.
Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Toy Hunter
The wildcard
Something you would not have found on your own.
Nightcrawler2014
Both explore the rush of finding something valuable others missed—but Nightcrawler asks what kind of person that hunger actually creates.
A taut thriller about a man obsessed with acquiring footage others won't—a different kind of hunt, same predatory hunger to possess what's rare and valuable. The moral rot beneath collecting culture laid bare.
But Extremely dark and cynical; uncomfortable to watch by design, with no warm resolution or satisfaction, only escalating moral corruption.
More like this (6)
Comic Book Men2012
Kevin Smith and his crew run a New Jersey comic shop and hunt for inventory. Deep nerd knowledge, genuine passion for pop culture history, and the banter feels real even when the stakes don't.
But Heavily dependent on Smith's comedy sensibility; if his voice and humor don't land for you, the show wears thin quickly.
Expedition Unknown2015
Josh Gates travels globally to solve mysteries, find lost items, and meet collectors. Adventure-focused rather than transaction-focused, with real curiosity and likable companionship driving each episode.
But Sometimes plays fast and loose with history for drama; the mystery elements can feel manufactured compared to the travel itself.
The Repair Shop2017
British artisans restore cherished broken objects—toys, furniture, instruments—with real skill and emotional depth. Slower, meditative, and genuinely moving when items hold deep personal history.
But Very gentle and therapeutic, which means very slow; if you want energy and hustle, this will feel like watching paint dry.
Salvage Hunters2011
Drew Pritchard and his team hunt UK car boots and auctions for vintage finds to restore and resell. Knowledgeable eye, real restoration work shown, and genuine camaraderie between the hosts.
But Less polished than American equivalents; some episodes focus heavily on the hosts' banter rather than the actual items being hunted.
Made in Abyss2017
Strip away commerce and nostalgia: at its heart, Toy Hunter is about the primal urge to descend into unknown places to retrieve precious objects. Made in Abyss is that instinct rendered literal and mythic.
An anime about two children descending into a vast mysterious pit to retrieve artifacts and uncover its secrets. Gorgeously animated, genuinely thrilling treasure-hunting adventure with real consequences and world-building depth.
But Anime aesthetics and pacing may alienate viewers expecting live-action; the show shifts into genuinely horrific territory in later episodes, abandoning adventure-show comfort entirely.
Halt and Catch Fire2014
Both chronicle people who can't stop hunting for the next thing. Halt and Catch Fire asks what happens when the hunt becomes the entire point of living.
A drama about obsessive tech entrepreneurs building computers in 1980s Texas—the same hunger to source rare components, make something valuable, sell it at market. But set entirely in a fictional world exploring ambition and legacy.
But Slow-burn character drama focused on relationships and ego; if you want collecting action and finds, this is a meditation on why people collect instead.
