Television series

The Pembrokeshire Murders

Name: The Pembrokeshire Murders
Genre: Drama, Crime
Released: 2021
Cast: Luke Evans, Keith Allen, Alexandria Riley, Caroline Berry, Oliver Ryan

A Welsh detective reopens two brutal unsolved murders from the 1980s using cutting-edge forensic science. Sharp, methodical, and genuinely tense, it's less flashy procedural and more quiet detective work—real ingenuity meeting real stakes. For anyone who loves watching smart people solve impossible puzzles without the melodrama.

TVMaze rating

3.9

If you liked this

Line of Duty2012

Intense procedural about corrupt police, built on meticulous investigation and moral ambiguity. Every episode earns its tension through character work and puzzle-box plotting rather than action or shock.

But The accent-heavy dialogue and acronym-heavy script can feel impenetrable. If you need plot clarity handed to you, this will frustrate.

MINDHUNTER2017

Two FBI profilers hunt serial killers in the 1970s by studying psychology rather than forensics. Cerebral, methodical, and genuinely unsettling—it respects your intelligence and the complexity of its subjects.

But Pacing is glacial by design; if you want forward momentum or neat resolutions, you'll feel stranded. It's deliberately unresolved.

Broadchurch2013

A small English community shattered by a child's murder. Bleakly acted, perfectly structured, and driven by genuine mystery rather than spectacle. David Tennant's detective work is methodical and wounded.

But Relentlessly grim and claustrophobic; it doesn't offer emotional release or comfort. Some find the atmosphere suffocating rather than gripping.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Pembrokeshire Murders

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Tin Star2017

Both follow a meticulous detective using specialized knowledge to solve old crimes, but Tin Star flips the moral frame—a detective who's part of the problem learning to be part of a solution.

A disgraced British detective reinvents himself as sheriff in a Canadian oil town. Taut, nasty, and brilliantly acted by Tim Roth—it pairs forensic procedure with a man rebuilding identity in hostile territory, like Pembrokeshire's methodical detective work filtered through moral compromise.

But Switches tones between procedural and revenge thriller, sometimes jarring. The violence can feel gratuitous rather than purposeful. Series declines noticeably after season one.

Luther2010

Brilliant, obsessive detective hunting serial killers through raw psychological insight. Idris Elba commands every frame, and the writing balances procedural rigor with character depth that actually lands.

But Later seasons lose the plot precision of the early ones and veer toward soap opera melodrama. The central detective's genius occasionally contradicts his competence.

Happy Valley2014

Yorkshire detective sergeant hunting a killer who destroyed her family. Sarah Lancashire delivers a masterclass in restraint; the writing is sharp, the mystery genuinely gripping, the emotional core unflinching.

But Bleaker than most dramas and focused more on trauma than resolution. The violence is infrequent but when it lands, it lands hard.

Bodyguard2018

Taut six-part thriller about a soldier assigned to protect a controversial politician. Every episode ends on a genuine twist; the plotting is surgical and the paranoia feels earned rather than manufactured.

But Relies on coincidence in the finale that strains credibility. The social commentary can feel heavy-handed in places.

The Fall2013

Stella Gibson hunts a meticulous serial killer through Belfast. Stella Collinson directs ice-cold cat-and-mouse tension; Gillian Anderson and Jamie Dornan create a psychological duel that unfolds across three seasons.

But Graphic depictions of sexual violence. Some viewers find the killer romanticized despite the show's intent; pacing falters in season three.

Mare of Easttown2021

Kate Winslet as a Pennsylvania detective investigating a teenage girl's murder while her own life fractures. Emotionally sophisticated, beautifully shot, and the mystery actually matters to the characters in believable ways.

But Character-focused rather than plot-driven; the whodunit elements take a back seat to grief and regret. If you want puzzle-solving, this prioritizes feeling.

Unforgotten2015

A skeleton found in London kicks off an investigation that unravels decades-old secrets. Each season methodically traces backward through time; the writing is intelligent and the ensemble cast elevates every scene.

But Slower burn than comparable shows; the payoff is character revelation rather than shocking twists. Some find the pacing meditative to the point of languid.

Des2020

Pembrokeshire uses forensic evidence to unmask a killer; Des uses forensic detail to unmask a mind. Both are about the precision of investigation laying truth bare.

A three-part drama about serial killer Dennis Nilsen told from his own fractured perspective. Unsettling and brilliantly acted by David Tennant; it's a masterclass in how forensic detail becomes the language of justice and confession.

But Deeply disturbing content focused on a real killer and real victims. The sympathetic framing may repel viewers—it's about understanding, not condemning, which feels morally complicated.