Television series
The Adventures of Wild Bill Hickok
A 1951 ABC Western about the legendary marshal Wild Bill Hickok and his chatty deputy Jingles. Half-hour episodes of frontier justice and gunfights, brisk and uncomplicated, with a comedy duo dynamic that carries you through. It's for anyone who wants their Westerns straightforward: good guys win, bad guys lose, move on to the next town by sundown.
If you liked this
Gunsmoke1955
The template for the adult Western series: a marshal in a real town dealing with genuine moral complications, not just shoot-outs. Matt Dillon's Dodge City feels lived-in and consequential in ways that shaped everything after.
But Twenty seasons is a commitment, and the early episodes move with glacial pacing compared to what you're used to. Some find Arness's stolid delivery dull.
The Virginian1962
A working cowboy instead of a lawman, but the same DNA: a strong man in a frontier town, weekly standalone stories, that perfect balance between action and character. Ninety minutes per episode means real breathing room.
But It runs long and can feel stagy. The philosophical conversations don't land unless you're already invested in the slow burn.
Bonanza1959
Family-centred Western with the same kind of episodic charm: a settled base (the Ponderosa), interesting visitors and problems, adventure that resolves by episode's end. Genuinely funny and surprisingly warm.
But The pacing is slow and the dialogue sometimes sentimental. Lorne Greene's patriarchal gravitas can feel heavy-handed.
Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Adventures of Wild Bill Hickok
The wildcard
Something you would not have found on your own.
Johnny Guitar1954
Both feature a lawman or gunslinger protecting a town from bad men, but Johnny Guitar inverts every Western assumption: the hero is a woman, the villain is a woman, and the story is about desire and loyalty rather than justice.
A Western directed by Nicholas Ray, shot in Trucolor, where the saloon owner is a woman with a gun and the emotional centre is a love triangle between two women. It's bizarre, operatic, visually stunning, and absolutely unlike anything else in the genre.
But The plot is threadbare and the dialogue occasionally stilted. Joan Crawford chewing scenery doesn't work if you're not ready for that kind of camp seriousness.
More like this (7)
The Lone Ranger1949
A masked hero and his sidekick riding out to help the innocent: the same buddy dynamic as Hickok and Jingles, with a bit more moral clarity. Brisk, engaging, unapologetically heroic.
But The masked avenger thing plays as campy now, and the pacing is frenetic in a way that can feel exhausting rather than exciting.
Wanted: Dead or Alive1958
Steve Reeves as a bounty hunter roaming from town to town, thirty-minute episodes, straightforward stories about catching bad guys. The kind of solid workmanlike Western that never embarrasses itself.
But Reeves is more muscle than actor, and the scripts are thin. It all feels a bit mechanical if you're not in the mood for formula.
Rawhide1959
A cattle drive with a rotating cast of guest stars, each episode a different problem or visitor on the trail. Less about law and order, more about frontier life itself. Clint Eastwood before he was famous.
But The premise gets repetitive: cattle + problem + resolution. The drama often feels forced and the pacing drags.
Laramie1959
Two ranchers helping out in their small town, gentle and episodic, with that same steady-handed approach to frontier life. More character-focused than gunplay-focused, which gives it unexpected depth.
But It's quiet to the point of slowness, and the stakes never feel very high. If you want action and urgency, this will feel like wading through mud.
The Man from Laramie1955
A Western about a man hunting his brother's killer, with real emotional complications and some surprisingly dark moments. James Stewart brings genuine vulnerability to the role, and the landscape feels hostile rather than picturesque.
But It's more noir than adventure, and the pacing is deliberate. Some find Stewart's softer approach to the Western leading man unconvincing.
The Ballad of Little Jo1993
Where Hickok and Jingles operate within the world of settled law and order, Jo has to invent a false identity to live in a lawless one. Both are about a person asserting themselves against a harsh landscape, but Jo's struggle is existential, not just professional.
Based on a true story, a woman dresses as a man to survive the frontier, and the film quietly dismantles every myth about the Old West: about gender, about honour, about what freedom actually meant. Suzy Amis is extraordinary, and the cinematography is beautiful and austere.
But It's a revisionist Western with a modern sensibility; there's no heroic gunplay, and the tone is melancholic. If you want adventure, you'll find only survival here.
Red River1948
Both follow a lawman/authority figure managing a group of men across hostile territory, but where Hickok's world resolves in half an hour, Hawks stretches his to mythic proportions and asks uncomfortable questions about who deserves to lead.
Howard Hawks' cattle-drive epic, John Wayne and Montgomery Clift on the Chisholm Trail, shot in black and white with real mythic weight. It's about ambition and obsession and the cost of leadership, and it moves like a epic poem. One of the greatest Westerns ever made.
But It's three hours long and shot in monochrome, and Wayne plays a ruthless tyrant for most of it. If you want a straightforward hero, he's compromised and difficult here.
