Film

Wish Upon

A teenager finds an antique music box that grants wishes—for a price paid in someone else's life. It's glossy, gruesome, PG-13-adjacent teen horror that swaps subtlety for satisfying, elaborately staged deaths. Not scary so much as morbidly fun, like watching dominoes fall in slow motion. Best for horror fans who want body count over dread.

TMDb rating5.7

If you liked this

Final Destination2000

The original template for death-as-a-puzzle horror—elaborate, cruel, wonderfully staged accidents that make you gasp before you laugh. Wish Upon owes it almost everything structurally.

But The effects and fashion are pure 2000, and the sequels diluted the formula into self-parody long before this one aged.

Final Destination poster

Drag Me to Hell2009

Sam Raimi at his gleeful best: a curse, a countdown, and increasingly outrageous set pieces played with total commitment to both horror and comedy.

But It's broader and gorier than Wish Upon, closer to a haunted-house rollercoaster than a moody teen thriller.

Drag Me to Hell poster

It Follows2015

A curse passed like a virus, dread that builds instead of erupts, and a synth score that turns suburban streets sinister. Elevated teen horror done right.

But Slow-burn and ambiguous where Wish Upon is fast and literal—if you want kills, this tests your patience first.

It Follows poster

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Monkey's Paw1933no page yet

Wish Upon is essentially a YA remake of this century-old cautionary tale about wishes that always collect their debt.

A creaky black-and-white B-movie built entirely on the same premise Wish Upon modernized: three wishes, each paid for in blood. Seeing the original mechanism, stripped of teen-movie gloss, is oddly chilling.

But It's slow, stagey, and dated in every technical sense—pure vintage horror with none of the polish or pace of modern cinema.

More like this (8)

Truth or Dare2018

A cursed game instead of a cursed box, but the same engine: teens dying in inventive ways because they wanted something for nothing.

But Critically it fared worse than Wish Upon—campier, sillier, and less confident in its own premise.

Truth or Dare poster

The Craft1996

Teenage girls discover real power and it costs them everything—a 90s classic about wanting more than you're allowed to have, with genuine style and bite.

But It's more coven drama than kill-of-the-week horror, so the pacing and tone feel distinctly different.

The Craft poster

Happy Death Day2017

A high schooler trapped in a magical loop that keeps killing her—clever, funny, and surprisingly warm underneath the slasher mechanics.

But It's more comedy than dread; if you want Wish Upon's grimness, this is a tonal left turn.

Happy Death Day poster

Jennifer's Body2009

Teen girl gets supernatural power, boys start dying, and the film is smarter and funnier about female rage than its marketing ever let on.

But Diablo Cody's dialogue is an acquired taste—arch and quippy in a way that can feel more knowing than scary.

Jennifer's Body poster

Ouija2014no page yet

Cursed object, teenage cast, escalating supernatural deaths—structurally the closest cousin to Wish Upon you'll find, beat for beat.

But It's widely considered the weaker version of this exact idea—competent but forgettable.

The Babysitter2017no page yet

A teen discovers something dark going on that costs lives, but here it's played almost entirely for gonzo, blood-splattered comedy.

But Netflix house style, broad humor, and a much campier register than Wish Upon's straighter horror.

Death Note2006

Same premise as Wish Upon—a young person, a magic object, a body count—played straight as moral tragedy instead of slasher fun.

A teenager finds an object that grants terrifying power over who lives and dies, and the show is a tense, brilliant cat-and-mouse chess match about what that corrupts in him.

But It's a subtitled anime series with dozens of episodes—a serious time investment if you wanted a quick self-contained horror fix.

Death Note poster

The Butterfly Effect2004

Strips out the supernatural horror trappings but keeps the exact engine: wishing something different always costs a life you didn't expect.

Every attempt to fix the past makes things worse, and someone else pays the price—the same escalating-cost structure as Wish Upon, but rendered as grief-soaked sci-fi drama instead of horror.

But It's heavier and sadder than anything Wish Upon attempts, with none of the campy, gory release valve.

The Butterfly Effect poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

Obsession