Film

The Rage: Carrie 2

A 1999 sequel that ditches the supernatural mystery for straight-up revenge: when a telekinetic outcast is cornered by jocks, she levels them with her mind. It's slick '90s horror that knows exactly what it is—less interested in scares than satisfaction. For fans who want Carrie's rage without the ambiguity.

TMDb rating2.9

If you liked this

Jawbreaker1999

Same year, same high school cruelty engine: a prank goes catastrophically wrong and the perpetrators face swift, escalating consequences. Darkly funny and nasty in ways the studio barely allowed.

But Campy in a way that requires commitment. Some find it too arch; others find it not arch enough. The tone ping-pongs.

Jawbreaker poster

I Know What You Did Last Summer1997

The template for '90s teen horror where secrets detonate in real time. Slick, propulsive, and more interested in the social stakes than jump scares. Sidney Prescott energy without being Scream.

But Relies on a reveal that doesn't hold up if you pause to think for five seconds. Requires you to surrender logic for momentum.

I Know What You Did Last Summer poster

Cruel Intentions1999

Same year, same sadistic teen universe. Poisonous private-school game-playing that ends in genuine wreckage. Less horror, more moral collapse—but the pleasure of watching it unfold is identical.

But The sex feels quaint now. Also, it's a Dangerous Liaisons riff disguised as teen noir, which can feel precious depending on your patience.

Cruel Intentions poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Rage: Carrie 2

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Fury1978

Both are stories of hunted telekinetic teenagers who stop running and start destroying. The Fury is the prototype; Carrie 2 is the MTV remake.

Brian De Palma's telekinetic-teen thriller that *actually* invented this DNA. A girl weaponizes her own power in a climax of operatic, furious destruction. Carrie 2 is basically fan fiction of this, but the original still hits harder.

But Slow-burn '70s pacing. The first act is methodical, almost bureaucratic. If you want propulsion, this will test you.

The Fury poster
More like this (7)

The Faculty1998

Aliens-in-the-school paranoia that treats teenagers as actual protagonists. Fast, smart enough, and genuinely fun about the genre machinery. Robert Rodriguez keeps it bouncing.

But Too aware of itself sometimes. Leans on self-aware winking when the premise would carry it alone.

The Faculty poster

Disturbing Behavior1998

Small-town strangeness where teenagers sense something warped beneath the wholesome surface. Moody and weird, with a genuine unsettling core underneath the teen-movie framing.

But Veers into preposterous territory in the third act. The payoff doesn't quite earn the buildup, and the ending feels hurried.

Disturbing Behavior poster

Urban Legend1998

Urban-legend murders stalking a college campus with actual style. Jared Leto and Tara Reid in a slasher that's confident about its own artifice. Surprisingly graphic for its era.

But The final twist is silly. And once you know it, there's not much to return to—the whole thing deflates a bit.

Urban Legend poster

The Craft1996

Teen outcasts finding power through an occult angle. Style-heavy, atmospheric, and oddly sincere about the allure of control. Fairuza Balk eats the whole film in the best way.

But Hasn't aged as gracefully as it thinks. The messaging about female power can feel muddled under the goth aesthetics.

The Craft poster

Cherry Falls2000

A slasher that flips its premise on its head with genuine wit. Knows it's ludicrous and leans into that. Treats its teenage cast with actual intelligence, which is rarer than it should be.

But Cheap production values in ways that work against the intention. Also, it's aggressively weird about sex in ways that might rankle.

Cherry Falls poster

Idle Hands1999

Same year, same B-movie energy but entirely committed to the bit. A stoner's hands become possessed and turn him into a killer—it's exactly as silly as it sounds and exactly as fun.

But The comedy undercuts any real tension. If you wanted horror with stakes, this flips the bird at that idea. Requires a specific mood to work.

Idle Hands poster

Heathers1989

Both are about teenagers committing atrocities against their peers, but one weaponizes the mind and one weaponizes opportunity. Same rage, different tools.

Not horror in the supernatural sense, but the moral horror of what high schoolers will do to each other. Jet black comedy-thriller where cruelty is the actual villain. Winona Ryder and Christian Slater in a massacre that's funny and devastating.

But Very dark. The body count is real, the stakes are real, and it doesn't flinch. Some find it too mean-spirited to enjoy.

Heathers poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by