Film

It Happened to Jane

Name: It Happened to Jane
Genre: Comedy, Romance
Released: 1959
Cast: Doris Day, Jack Lemmon, Ernie Kovacs, Steve Forrest, Teddy Rooney

Comedy
Light-hearted

A cheerful Doris Day comedy about a scrappy Maine lobster businesswoman who sues a railroad baron and discovers romance with her idealistic young lawyer. It's bright, efficiently paced, and full of that golden-age Hollywood charm—snappy dialogue, real chemistry, and genuine warmth underneath the jokes. Made for anyone who likes their comedies with heart and their heroines with backbone.

TMDb rating

3.1

If you liked this

Pillow Talk1959

Day and Rock Hudson spark magnificently in this battle-of-the-sexes romp about a songwriter and an interior decorator sharing a telephone line. The banter is sharp, the schemes are elaborate, and there's real affection underneath.

But The gender politics are very much of their era, and if you find that stuff grating, there's no escaping it here.

Breakfast at Tiffany's1961

Audrey Hepburn as a free-spirited New York woman charming her way through life. Same era, same elegance, similar blend of comedy and romance wrapped in gorgeous production design.

But The supporting characters include some truly uncomfortable racial stereotypes that haven't aged well and are hard to ignore.

The Philadelphia Story1940

A sparkling screwball comedy about a wealthy woman navigating two very different men and her own stubborn nature. Cary Grant, Jimmy Stewart, and Katharine Hepburn firing on all cylinders.

But It's very talk-heavy and very much a product of 1940—some viewers find the pacing feels leisurely by modern standards.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from It Happened to Jane

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Gidget1959

Both are about unconventional women insisting on their own agency and having fun doing it—one in a Maine lobster boat, one on a surfboard, but the spirit is identical.

Sandra Dee as a spirited girl discovering surfing and independence in California. Same year as *Jane*, same peppy energy and heroine refusing to be kept in a box, but it's a whole different world and tone—youthful, colorful, surprisingly modern in its gender politics.

But The surfing scenes feel very dated, and if you're not charmed by that particular California-60s aesthetic, it won't win you over.

Funny Face1957

Fred Astaire and Audrey Hepburn in a romantic comedy about a bookish woman transformed into a fashion model. The dancing is ethereal, the music is perfect, the banter crackles.

But The whole premise hinges on a woman needing a man to make her interesting, which doesn't sit well with everyone.

Roman Holiday1953

Audrey Hepburn as a runaway princess spending a magical day in Rome with Gregory Peck. Charming, romantic, beautiful, and genuinely touching despite its lightness.

But It's entirely conventional in structure and emotional beats, and some find it a bit too precious to fully invest in.

It Should Happen to You1954

Judy Holliday as an unemployed woman who becomes famous for renting a billboard with her name on it. Sharp script, genuine charm, and Holliday is magnificent—a perfect balance of comedy and heart.

But The satire on fame feels gentle and quaint now, and the ending is predictably tidy.

Sabrina1954

Audrey Hepburn catches between two wealthy brothers. Billy Wilder directs with style, the romance is genuinely engaging, and the dialogue has real snap.

But Hepburn's character exists entirely in relation to men and their approval, which can feel limiting if that bothers you.

Teacher's Pet1958

Doris Day opposite Clark Gable in a newspaperman-versus-journalism-teacher romance. It's got the same brisk energy and genuine chemistry as *It Happened to Jane*, with excellent supporting work from Gig Young.

But The plot is thin enough to see through, and if you're not invested in the leads' charm, there's not much scaffolding underneath.

The Egg and I1947

Claudette Colbert and Fred MacMurray in a rural comedy about newlyweds learning to farm in Washington state. Sweet-natured, funny, and surprisingly touching about marriage and compromise.

But It's slower-paced than the snappier comedies of the era, and the rural setting means less visual glamour.

The Lady Eve1941

Both are about women outsmarting powerful men through sheer determination and charm, but where *Jane* is earnest and sunny, *The Lady Eve* is morally ambiguous and deliciously nasty.

Barbara Stanwyck as a con artist who seduces a naive millionaire aboard a ship. Preston Sturges directing at peak wit—the dialogue is absolutely relentless, the comedy is sophisticated, and Stanwyck is wicked and radiant.

But It's much darker and more cynical than *Jane*, and the pacing assumes you're quick enough to catch every joke; if you miss the rhythms, it can feel scattered.