Film

I Love You Again

Name: I Love You Again
Genre: Comedy, Romance
Released: 1940
Cast: William Powell, Myrna Loy, Frank McHugh, Edmund Lowe, Donald Douglas

Screwball comedy
Light-hearted

A 1940 screwball comedy where a dull businessman recovers from amnesia to find he's actually a charming con artist—and madly in love with the wife he was divorcing. William Powell and Myrna Loy crackle with chemistry through zippy dialogue and increasingly absurd situations. It's pure escapist fun: witty, fleet-footed, built for people who think fast and laugh faster.

TMDb rating

3.6

If you liked this

The Thin Man1934

Powell and Loy's definitive pairing: a married detective duo solving crimes with quips, cocktails, and genuine affection. If you loved their rhythm in I Love You Again, this is the template that made them irresistible.

But It's a 1930s mystery, so the plot mechanics feel a touch creaky now. The pacing assumes patience for exposition.

Libeled Lady1936

Powell leads a screwball ensemble (Jean Harlow, Myrna Loy, Spencer Tracy) through a wildly plotted newspaper scheme. Rapid-fire dialogue, romantic tangles, and nobody plays comedy quite like Powell in his prime.

But It moves so fast the plot becomes almost incidental. If you need clarity over chaos, you'll be lost.

My Man Godfrey1936

Carole Lombard and Powell spark in this Depression-era comedy about a screwball heiress and a mysterious drifter. Smart, funny, and genuinely touching—proof that 1930s Hollywood knew how to do comedy.

But Screwball energy can feel manic if you're not in the mood. Some jokes land on outdated assumptions.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from I Love You Again

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

His Girl Friday1940

Both turn on a couple realizing they belong together despite (or because of) chaos and deception. The pace and verbal wit are nearly identical; the setting is the only difference.

Rosalind Russell and Cary Grant in a newspaper office, overlapping dialogue at machine-gun speed. It's the same screwball DNA as I Love You Again but in a different costume—a remake of The Front Page that's actually better than the original.

But The rapid-fire overlapping dialogue is exhausting if you're not locked in. If you want to relax, this demands focus.

The Philadelphia Story1940

Cary Grant, Katherine Hepburn, James Stewart: a masterpiece about love, remarriage, and people who say brilliant things under pressure. Same year as I Love You Again but operating at peak sophistication.

But It's more elegant than funny. If you want jokes over feeling, this will feel slow.

Twentieth Century1934

John Barrymore and Carole Lombard trade insults on a cross-country train. It's controlled chaos—theatrical, witty, a direct ancestor to screwball's best moments.

But Barrymore's hamming can feel excessive. The theatrical zaniness won't appeal to everyone.

It Happened One Night1934

Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert on a road trip, sparring and falling for each other. The template for romantic comedy itself: warm, funny, genuinely inventive.

But It's foundational, which means it feels familiar now. You might feel like you've seen it before you watch it.

The Awful Truth1937

Cary Grant and Irene Dunne as a divorcing couple sabotaging each other with charm and scheming. The emotional heart beneath the chaos—separation and second thoughts, played as high comedy.

But Some plot elements haven't aged gracefully. The dog-centered subplot will test your patience.

Ninotchka1939

Greta Garbo, rarely heard to laugh, plays a Soviet agent undone by Paris and Melvyn Douglas. Elegant, smart, funny in a way that feels effortless. Political and romantic at once.

But It's glacial compared to American screwball. If you want pace over subtlety, it'll feel slow.

Topper1937

Cary Grant and Constance Bennett as ghosts haunting Cosmo Topper. High-concept comedy done with charm and genuine wit; a ghost story that's actually funny.

But The supernatural premise is underbaked. It has charm but not much substance beneath it.

The Lady Eve1941

Both stories pivot on the same mechanism: a charming deceiver reveals themselves to someone they love, only to find the love was real all along. Same emotional architecture, higher comic stakes.

Barbara Stanwyck cons a naive millionaire played by Henry Fonda. Preston Sturges at peak form: the plot flips halfway through, the con becomes love becomes con again. Dazzling.

But It's more structurally complex than I Love You Again. If you want straightforward, this layers twist onto twist.

Some Like It Hot1959

Takes the screwball premise—create a false identity to escape consequences, fall in love anyway—and makes it existential. I Love You Again asks 'what if you forgot who you were?' Some Like It Hot asks 'what if you became someone else entirely?' Same question, different century.

Tony Curtis, Jack Lemmon, Marilyn Monroe on the run from gangsters in drag. Possibly the funniest film ever made. Screwball logic pushed to its logical extreme: identity, desire, romance, and impeccable comic timing.

But It's almost twenty years later and feels like a different world. The gender-play premise, while brilliant, lands differently now.