Film

God Help the Girl

Name: God Help the Girl
Genre: Comedy, Drama, Music
Released: 2014
Cast: Emily Browning, Olly Alexander, Hannah Murray, Pierre Boulanger, Cora Bissett

Musical

Stuart Murdoch's musical about three misfits forming a band in Glasgow is a buoyant, melancholic joy. It's a film that trusts music to say what dialogue can't, mixing whimsy with real loneliness. For anyone who's ever felt like an outsider looking in, or who believes a perfect song can rewire your brain.

TMDb rating

3.3

If you liked this

Once2007

An Irish musician and a Czech immigrant fall into songwriting together. It's similarly tender, similarly built on the belief that music is how broken people touch each other. Stripped-down and genuine.

But The romance can feel slight if you're not already invested in the power of connection through melody. Some find it precious.

Sing Street2016

Dublin teenager forms a band to impress a girl in the 1980s. Has the same infectious energy, the same sense that music is salvation, and the same gift for making you believe in these kids completely.

But More straightforwardly uplifting than God Help the Girl. If you want something darker or more complex, this is too much sunshine.

Moonlight2016

Three chapters of a young Black man's life, exploring identity and connection. Like God Help the Girl, it's quiet and lyrical, trusting the viewer to feel what's unsaid. Music is woven through, not narrative.

But Structurally experimental and emotionally heavy. There's no plot in the conventional sense, which can feel frustrating if you need clear forward momentum.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from God Help the Girl

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Daria1997

Both explore what happens when sensitivity and misfitness collide with the world's indifference. Both let outsiders be right.

A caustic teenage girl navigates a world that doesn't fit her. It's comedy made from alienation, from being too smart and too honest for the people around you. Eve would recognise herself in Daria's deadpan refusal.

But Animated sitcom from the early 2000s with a laugh track. The aesthetic is dated; the humour assumes you know MTV culture. Some will find it too knowing.

Aftersun2022

A father and daughter on holiday; memory and music collapse into each other. Gorgeously strange and wound tight with unexpressed feeling. You'll leave thinking about loneliness and love.

But Deliberately opaque. It doesn't explain itself or provide easy answers. Some will find that beautiful; others exhausting.

Heartbeats2010

Two friends fall in love with the same person over a Montreal summer. It has the same gossamer quality, the same sense of watching young people navigate desire and friendship with no map.

But Openly romantic and stylised in ways that feel dated now. If artifice puts you off, this won't work.

Under the Skin2014

Scarlett Johansson as an alien encountering Glasgow. Hypnotic, strange, and achingly lonely. Another film that lets atmosphere and music do the heavy lifting instead of explanation.

But Not a narrative in any traditional sense. Deliberately alienating. You have to surrender to its logic or you'll spend two hours frustrated.

The Florida Project2017

Children living in a motel near Disney World. Shot with lyrical tenderness despite the poverty. It captures the same magic-making spirit: finding joy and community in marginal places.

But Slow and observational. Nothing happens in plot terms. The beauty is glacial if you're not primed for it.

Hunt for the Wilderpeople2016

An old hunter and a foster kid bonding in the New Zealand bush. It's funny and tender in equal measure, about found family and the way misfits fit together.

But More conventionally charming than God Help the Girl. If you're after something weirder or more unsettling, this is too comfortable.

A Ghost Story2017

A man returns to his house as a ghost after death. Experimental, strange, and deeply moving about time and connection. Music punctuates the silence beautifully.

But The central image (a sheet-covered figure) could feel gimmicky. Some will find the pacing unbearably slow. It requires patience and openness.

Three Colors: Blue1993

Both believe music can express what words cannot. Both understand that beauty and pain are often the same thing.

A woman loses her family in an accident and tries to erase herself from the world. Kieslowski's meditation on grief and music: blue is the colour of forgetting, and a piano is the only way out. Incandescent.

But A Kieslowski film on grief: it's austere, philosophical, asks a lot of the viewer. Not comforting. The ending offers no resolution, only acceptance.