Film

Beautiful Girls

A 1996 ensemble comedy-drama about male friendship and romantic fumbling in a small Massachusetts town. It's wistful and funny without being mean, populated by real people making small mistakes. It works best if you remember what it felt like to be adrift in your twenties, watching your friends make choices you didn't understand.

TMDb rating3.3

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you love ensemble films about men stalled between youth and adulthood, where the talk is sharp, shaggy and funny and the melancholy sneaks in under the banter.

Skip it if you want a clear plot with steady momentum, since this drifts from one hangout and one bar conversation to the next and rarely pushes toward a destination.

What it asks of you: Settle in for a loose, unhurried 112 minutes of overlapping conversations, with the mood shifting between wry comedy and quiet ache.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

Reality Bites1994

Captures the same generational uncertainty—smart people in their twenties genuinely unsure what comes next, romance tangled up with ambition and self-doubt. Winona Ryder is luminous.

But The irony can feel dated, and the film sometimes mistakes surface-level cool for actual depth. Ethan Hawke's monologues don't always land.

Reality Bites poster

Diner1982

Barry Levinson's masterpiece about male friendship, late-night conversations, and the specific gravity of having grown up together. Less romantic but equally unsentimental about real connection.

But It's slower and stranger than you might expect. The emotional beats are quiet. If you need plot momentum, you'll feel adrift.

Diner poster

St. Elmo's Fire1985

Same DNA—a group in flux, trying to figure out adulthood, romantic entanglements that feel genuinely uncertain. Emilio Estevez and Rob Lowe are surprisingly effective in dramatic mode.

But It lurches between tones, and some of the romantic resolution feels forced. The 1980s aesthetic is vivid and occasionally unintentionally silly.

St. Elmo's Fire poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Beautiful Girls

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Daria1997

Both are interested in the interior lives of people stuck in small places, watching their peers conform in ways they don't quite understand. Both balance comedy and real loneliness without letting either completely win.

An animated series that captures the same small-town social awkwardness and the specific pain of watching people make choices you don't understand. Genuinely smart and deeply empathetic about loneliness. Ten times more clever than it needs to be.

But It's animated, which stops some people cold. The deadpan tone takes an episode or two to click. It's more interested in character than plot.

Daria poster
More like this (8)

High Fidelity2000

Another film about arrested development and the ways men construct identity through taste and friendship. Funny, sad, and completely honest about how badly people can hurt each other unintentionally.

But John Cusack breaks the fourth wall constantly, which some find mannered. The resolution doesn't fully satisfy the questions the film asks.

High Fidelity poster

When Harry Met Sally...1989

Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks navigate the question of whether men and women can be friends without romance interfering. It's funny, warm, and genuinely insightful about desire and companionship.

But Some find the ending romantic-comedy predictable. The New York setting and coffee-shop philosophy can feel precious depending on your mood.

When Harry Met Sally... poster

The Brothers McMullen1995

Edward Burns' scrappy, genuine film about three brothers working through faith, marriage, and brotherhood. It has Beautiful Girls' earnestness without trying to be slick.

But Made on a shoestring budget and it shows—rough around the edges. The romantic philosophizing will feel either honest or repetitive depending on how you're feeling.

The Brothers McMullen poster

Glory Days1988

A deceptively touching film about male friendship and the moment when the things that bonded you stop being enough. Very much in the same emotional register.

But It's genuinely melancholy in ways that undercut the comedy. Some may find it too heavy-handed about the passage of time.

Glory Days poster

Four Rooms1995

A different approach to ensemble comedy—contained, weird, and ambitious. If you liked Beautiful Girls' sense of character and conversation, this proves conversations can sustain a feature.

But It's genuinely odd and doesn't cohere. Some will find it pretentious. The experimental structure alienates more people than it charms.

Four Rooms poster

The Dreamers2003

Bernardo Bertolucci's film about friendship, coming-of-age, and the ways love divides loyalties. A more adult, internationalist take on the same themes—slower but richer.

But Contains explicit sexual content. The pacing is unhurried. It requires patience and won't work if you want something breezy.

The Dreamers poster

The Straight Story1999

Same year as Beautiful Girls' emotional universe—male relationships that accumulate meaning through time rather than through conflict. Both ask: what happens when you stop being young and your friends still matter?

David Lynch's strangest film: a straight, sincere, almost gentle story about an elderly man riding a lawnmower across Iowa to reconnect with his estranged brother. It's about male friendship and time and regret without a trace of irony.

But There is almost no plot. It's 111 minutes of driving and conversations. If you want narrative momentum or tension, it will bore you severely.

The Straight Story poster

Magnolia1999

Both are fundamentally about the gap between how people present and who they actually are. Both trust their ensemble casts enough to give everyone real interior lives. Both understand that loneliness isn't primarily about being alone.

Paul Thomas Anderson's three-hour, ten-character epic about Los Angeles loneliness and the ways men and women talk past each other. It's baroque and ambitious and absolutely heartbroken. Contains one of the best ensemble casts ever assembled.

But It's very long. The tone is wildly uneven—it swings from comedy to tragedy to something stranger. The climax is genuinely divisive. Requires real engagement, not background watching.

Magnolia poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

Diner, Shall We Dance?, The Station Agent, The Last of the High Kings