Television series

Nancy Drew

Name: Nancy Drew
Genre: Drama, Mystery, Supernatural
Released: 2019
Cast: Leah Lewis, Maddison Jaizani, Tunji Kasim, Kennedy McMann, Alex Saxon

Other titles called Nancy Drew: the 2007 film.

A sharp, supernatural take on the Nancy Drew mythos. Moody, teen-oriented mystery with genuine scares and twists that don't telegraph themselves. It's *Riverdale* energy but smarter—less camp, more dread. Ideal for anyone who wants mystery writing that respects your intelligence and isn't afraid of the dark.

TVMaze rating

3.4

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you love a mystery that takes its time, where the supernatural hum under a small town's surface matters as much as the clues, and a teen-soap pulse keeps the pages turning.

Skip it if you want a clean, self-contained case each week; this runs long, leans on serialized threads and family drama, and the cases often feel like the excuse rather than the point.

What it asks of you: Sixty-odd hour-long episodes across four seasons, so it asks for a commitment, and it rewards patience with slow reveals rather than quick, tidy answers.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

Veronica Mars2004

Witty teen detective solving interconnected mysteries in a corrupt small town. Smarter dialogue, strong character work, and genuine moral complexity beneath the noir trappings. The blueprint for smart teen mystery.

But Veronica's voiceover can feel dated; the show sometimes prioritizes gags over stakes. If you want pure atmosphere over wit, this tilts the other way.

The Owl House2020

Supernatural mystery wrapped in character-driven drama. A teen navigates a magical world while piecing together dark secrets. Gorgeous animation, excellent pacing, and genuine emotional weight beneath the adventure.

But It's animated and aimed at a younger demo, which some find harder to sink into. Takes a few episodes to establish stakes.

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina2018

Teenage protagonist caught between supernatural forces and everyday life, balancing school with existential horror. Atmospheric, genuinely unsettling at its best, with real consequences for characters you care about.

But Uneven tonal control—veers between grim and silly. Later seasons lose focus; the mythology gets muddled.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Nancy Drew

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Twin Peaks1990

Both use murder and mystery as a vehicle to examine how trauma fractures a community. Both ask whether solving the mystery actually solves anything.

David Lynch's return to small-town mystery 25 years later. Weird, hypnotic, genuinely unsettling. The show asks what happens when a mystery *never* closes, and haunting becomes a way of life rather than a plot device.

But Deliberately paced for drift rather than propulsion. Obtuse in ways that reward obsession but punish casual viewing. Inaccessible without the original series.

The Midnight Club2022

Locked-room mystery with supernatural elements. Interwoven storylines, atmospheric dread, and a cast of teens you actually believe in. Tight, ten-episode arc that respects your time.

But Heavy subject matter (suicide, terminal illness) means it's not comfort viewing. Can be bleak in ways the mystery doesn't always balance.

Pretty Little Liars2010

Serialized mystery that keeps you theorizing. Multiple suspects, genuine surprises, and strong ensemble chemistry. Perfect if you want a show that rewards weekly watching and speculation.

But Mythology gets unnecessarily convoluted; the final reveal feels unearned. Some characters disappear and reappear arbitrarily.

Locke & Key2020

Supernatural family mystery with a puzzle-box structure. Strong production design, real scares, and the core mystery actually *matters* to character development. Visually inventive.

But Younger cast may feel young if you're outside the target demo. Inconsistent pacing in places; some episodes drag.

The Summer I Turned Pretty2022

Summer-set coming-of-age with mystery elements woven through. Character-focused, warm but with underlying tension. If you want less supernatural dread and more emotional stakes.

But Lighter tone means less mystery payoff. Love triangle plotting can overshadow the actual narrative drive.

Manifest2018

Supernatural mystery with a compelling central conceit. Everyday people unraveling impossible phenomena. Addictive if you love mythology-building and interconnected clues.

But Stretches its premise thin across four seasons; answers come late and sometimes feel arbitrary. Cancelled on a cliffhanger.

The Girlfriend Experience2016

Character study wrapped in mystery. Stunning cinematography, subtle storytelling, a protagonist you're trying to decode as much as the plot. Formally experimental in interesting ways.

But Deliberately cryptic and slow. If you want clarity and momentum, this frustrates. First season is strong; season two muddles it.

Crime Scene2021

Both explore how a death becomes a story, and how investigation distorts truth. The difference: Nancy solves it; this shows what happens when she never does.

Documentary about a real unsolved death that spirals into obsession. What starts as a mystery becomes a meditation on how the internet hunts, judges, and destroys. Propulsive but morally complex.

But A real tragedy at the center; no tidy resolution. Uncomfortable watching people weaponize amateur sleuthing. Requires emotional stamina.

Yellowjackets2021

Both are ensemble mysteries driven by teen perspectives, but Yellowjackets refuses the comfort of being solved. It's what happens to Nancy Drew's town after she's gone.

Supernatural mystery with serious, uncompromising storytelling. Teen plane-crash survivors and their fractured adult selves, unraveling what happened in the wilderness. Brilliantly structured, deeply unsettling, character-driven mystery at its finest.

But Heavily serialized; you must pay attention. Darker and more violent than it first appears. No neat answers yet, and the slow burn won't work if you need resolution.