Film

Tolkien

Name: Tolkien
Genre: War, Drama, Romance
Released: 2019
Cast: Nicholas Hoult, Lily Collins, Colm Meaney, Derek Jacobi, Harry Gilby

Biopic

Tolkien traces the formative years of the Oxford philologist and author, from his passionate schoolboy friendships through the trenches of the First World War. It's a literary biopic that treats its subject with genuine tenderness, exploring how grief, friendship and artistic yearning shaped the man who would create Middle-earth. For anyone who loves Tolkien's work or stories about how art emerges from trauma.

TMDb rating

3.5

If you liked this

The Imitation Game2014

A similarly structured portrait of a brilliant British mind—Alan Turing—navigating secrecy, isolation and the weight of his own genius. Cumberbatch's performance has the same wounded intensity Hoult brings here.

But It moves between timelines in ways that can feel choppy, and the emotional payoff depends on caring about a man who keeps everyone at arm's length.

Testament of Youth2015

Alicia Vikander's haunting performance anchors this story of a young writer finding her voice during and after the First World War. It shares Tolkien's elegiac tone and belief that art matters because loss matters.

But It's a quiet film about quiet suffering. If you need plot momentum or spectacle, this will feel glacial.

The Nightingale2018

Another portrait of artistic longing set against wartime devastation. It examines how beauty persists in brutality with the same tender seriousness that Tolkien brings to its subject matter.

But The violence is unflinching and the ending is deliberately bleak. Not a comfort watch.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Tolkien

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Journey's End2017

Both films believe that the First World War was the hinge on which an entire generation's souls turned. Where Tolkien contextualises trauma through a life, Journey's End lives inside it.

A single-location play adaptation set in a WWI trench in the final days before armistice. It's claustrophobic, intense and unsparingly focused on how young men fracture under pressure. No romance, no framing device—just the thing itself.

But It's ninety minutes of mounting dread with no relief. The theatrical origins mean long monologues; the setting means no visual variety. Punishing to watch.

A Serious Man2009

The Coens' meditation on faith, loss and the search for meaning among intellectual men. It has the same preoccupation with how personal catastrophe reshapes a worldview.

But It's cryptic and deliberately frustrating. Some viewers find it cold rather than moving.

Atonement2007

Joe Wright's baroque storytelling about how trauma and secrets metastasize through a life. Both films fixate on how young passions and wounds become the DNA of who we become.

But It's emotionally exhausting and ends in a place of deliberate, philosophical sadness rather than resolution.

The Theory of Everything2014

Redmayne as Stephen Hawking in a biopic that never condescends to its subject, finding grandeur in both the intellectual and the domestic. Shares Tolkien's interest in brilliant men navigating love and limitation.

But Oscar-bait biopics can feel obligatory. This one has restraint, but restraint isn't everyone's idea of cinema.

Parade's End2012

A five-hour miniseries of devastating emotional intelligence about honour, class and the psychic damage of the First World War. Deeply literary and deeply felt in the way Tolkien is.

But It's extremely long and very bleak. The narrative is fragmented and the protagonist is almost paralysed by his own code of ethics.

Darkest Hour2017

Gary Oldman as Churchill navigating impossible choices. Both films examine how historical figures with inner lives we think we know were actually shaped by forces and doubts that rarely make it into the textbooks.

But It's primarily a political thriller dressed as biography. If you want interiority over incident, you'll feel shortchanged.

Synecdoche, New York2008

Both explore how private loss becomes the engine of creation. Kaufman's artist builds his Middle-earth much as Tolkien did—as a way of ordering and surviving the unbearable.

Kaufman's singular vision of an artist constructing entire worlds inside his own grief and obsession. It's about the relationship between life and art, between what we experience and what we make from it.

But It's deliberately baffling, layered like an onion to the point of opacity. Some people find it brilliant; others find it pointlessly obscure.

A Ghost Story2017

Both are about how the dead speak to us through art and language. Where Tolkien imagines Middle-earth as a mirror of his grief, Affleck's ghost haunts the spaces where memory lives. Both understand that creation is a form of haunting.

A devastatingly original meditation on time, loss, memory and what we leave behind. Casey Affleck—barely visible under a sheet—gives one of cinema's most heartbreaking performances about witnessing a life you can no longer touch.

But It's deliberately slow and formally strange. One scene involves a monologue that goes on for several minutes without cuts. It will either transfix you or bore you to fury.