Film

Finders Keepers

Name: Finders Keepers
Genre: Mystery, Thriller, Horror
Released: 2014
Cast: Jaime Pressly, Kylie Rogers, Tobin Bell, Patrick Muldoon, Mark DeCarlo

A modest, made-for-TV haunted-doll chiller that does exactly what the title promises: a girl finds a sinister antique doll, her family starts unraveling, and Tobin Bell turns up as the one adult who suspects something's wrong. At 85 minutes it moves briskly, trades gore for mood, and works best as low-stakes, rainy-afternoon horror rather than anything that lingers.

TMDb rating

4.9

If you liked this

Annabelle2014

The doll movie that spawned an empire, released the same year and built on the same bones: a creepy vintage doll, a young family, and an opening scare that still lands. Slicker frights than Finders Keepers by design.

But It's a prequel cash-in with a plot that barely holds together, leaning hard on jump scares to cover the gaps.

Child's Play1988

The granddaddy of killer-doll cinema. Chucky's origin story still works because it commits fully to its absurd premise and never once winks at the audience about how silly it is.

But Dated effects and a goofy streak the sequels leaned into hard; some now find it funnier than frightening.

The Conjuring2013

Same haunted-object universe, a tier up in craft. James Wan's control of dread and patient camera work made this the gold standard for the genre Finders Keepers is quietly imitating.

But Its reputation may have oversold it; the scares are expertly engineered rather than genuinely unsettling for seasoned horror watchers.

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Trilogy of Terror1975

This is the ur-text: the segment 'Amelia' is the direct ancestor of every killer-doll movie made since, including the one you just watched.

Karen Black fighting a foot-tall Zuni warrior doll in a cramped apartment terrified a generation and effectively invented the small-object-big-violence subgenre that Finders Keepers is still working in decades later.

But It's a 1975 TV anthology with dated effects, and the other two segments are noticeably weaker than the famous one.

Dead Silence2007

Swap the doll for a ventriloquist dummy and get a nastier, gothic, more gleefully gruesome version of the same idea, from the director of Saw before he went big-budget.

But The tone swings wildly between camp and genuine horror, and the twist ending divides people hard.

Curse of Chucky2013no page yet

A direct-to-video sequel that quietly out-scares the glossy studio reboots by ditching one-liners for slow-burn tension and a genuinely creepy central performance.

But Low budget shows in places, and some familiarity with the Chucky mythology helps you get full value from it.

The Boy2016

The closest cousin to Finders Keepers in scale and setup: a nanny, an unnervingly lifelike doll, a big isolated house with secrets, right up until a swerve you won't see coming.

But That swerve either delights or infuriates viewers, and the back half essentially becomes a different movie.

Poltergeist1982

Proof this genre's roots run deep: a family menaced by object-possessed evil, plus the single scariest clown doll in movie history, still unmatched decades later.

But Eighties pacing and effects will feel slow to anyone used to modern jump-scare rhythms.

Ouija2014no page yet

Same year, same PG-13 haunted-object formula, same teen-cast energy — a good companion piece for seeing how differently two low-stakes horror movies handle nearly identical material.

But Critically maligned for a reason: thin characters and predictable scares make it a curiosity more than a recommendation.

Magic1978

Anthony Hopkins as a ventriloquist unraveling alongside his dummy, proof that 'unsettling object as extension of a fractured mind' has been working on audiences for decades.

But It's a slow psychological thriller, not a scare-a-minute horror film, and some will find it plodding.

Marwencol2010

Where Finders Keepers uses a doll as a vessel for menace, this uses dolls as a vessel for survival — same object, opposite emotional register.

A documentary about a man who, after a brutal assault, builds an entire miniature WWII town populated by dolls to survive his trauma — stranger, sadder, and more moving than any fiction.

But There's no horror here at all; it's a real, sometimes heartbreaking character study rather than a thriller.

The Innocents1961

Both hinge on whether a child is being corrupted by something unseen, and whether the adults around her will believe it in time.

A gorgeous, genuinely disquieting black-and-white ghost story about two children and the governess who fears something malevolent has claimed them — quiet dread instead of jump scares.

But Slow, literary, and deliberately ambiguous; nothing jumps out, and some will find it too restrained to satisfy.