Film

A Garfield Christmas

A gentle, half-hour Christmas special that captures Garfield at his most human—cynical but capable of genuine feeling. The orange cat travels to Jon's family farm and discovers something softer than his usual sardonic contempt. It's cozy without being saccharine, funny without trying too hard, and it understands that the best Christmas stories are about small acts of connection.

TMDb rating3.7

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you love a cosy, gently sardonic holiday special where the cat's selfish schemes are the main event and the Christmas sentiment arrives in small doses.

Skip it if you want a festive story with real emotional momentum, since this slight special trades plot for gags and mostly keeps Garfield pottering about.

What it asks of you: Expect a very short, undemanding watch with simple jokes and a light pace, asking little more than a willingness to settle in with a cartoon cat for twenty-four minutes.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

A Charlie Brown Christmas1965

The template for how to make a Christmas special that feels real—honest about disappointment and loneliness while still finding grace in modest gestures. Charlie Brown's struggle mirrors Garfield's arc perfectly.

But It's deliberately sparse and melancholy in places. If you want relentless cheer and spectacle, this won't deliver it.

A Charlie Brown Christmas poster

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer1964

Stop-motion puppetry, a huge heart, and genuine stakes despite the fantastical premise. It takes its characters seriously and lets them grow. The Island of Misfit Toys still resonates because the show respects difference.

But The pacing is measured and slow by modern standards. Some plot threads feel padded, and the voice acting is very much of its era.

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer poster

How the Grinch Stole Christmas!1966

Chuck Jones directing, Boris Karloff narrating, and a story about someone learning to feel—which is exactly what happens to Garfield. The animation is gorgeous, the message is earned, not forced.

But At 26 minutes it feels slight, and if you know the story too well already, there's less to discover.

How the Grinch Stole Christmas! poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from A Garfield Christmas

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Perfect Blue1998

Both use their medium's unique properties—Garfield through gentle humor and warmth, Perfect Blue through disorientation—to explore the gap between how the world sees us and who we actually are.

Satoshi Kon's psychological thriller uses animation not for whimsy but for nightmare—the fractured mind of a woman losing grip on reality. It proves animation can be as dark and adult as live-action, and demands your attention in ways Garfield doesn't.

But It's disturbing, fast-paced, and deliberately hard to follow. If you came for comfort, this will feel like a betrayal. Not a Christmas film by any measure.

Perfect Blue poster
More like this (7)

Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas1977

Jim Henson's Muppets in a story about family, self-sacrifice, and realizing what matters. It's funny and touching without being cute or treacly. The songs are genuinely good.

But Puppet-based comedy isn't for everyone. Some find the Muppet aesthetic dated or a bit unsettling rather than charming.

Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas poster

The Snowman1982

Twenty-six minutes of pure visual poetry set to Aled Jones. No dialogue, just atmosphere, wonder, and a genuine emotional gut-punch. If Garfield's quieter moments appeal to you, this will destroy you.

But It's silent and slow. There's no plot in the conventional sense. Impatience with pacing will kill it for you.

The Snowman poster

Frosty the Snowman1951

The Rankin/Bass style in miniature—simple animation, a moral core about letting go, and genuine melancholy underneath the holiday veneer. It's about acceptance and loss wrapped in snow.

But The animation is quite basic by modern standards, and the story is straightforward in a way that can feel thin if you're not in the mood for it.

Frosty the Snowman poster

The Year Without a Santa Claus1974

A deeper special than its reputation suggests: Santa questions whether anyone cares anymore, and the show takes that crisis seriously before resolving it. The Miser Brothers are genuinely funny.

But Stop-motion from this era has a particular texture some find creepy rather than charming. The message about believing can land as heavy-handed.

The Year Without a Santa Claus poster

Mickey's Christmas Carol1983

A tight, smart adaptation of Dickens that lets Disney characters carry real emotional weight. It understands that Scrooge stories work because transformation matters, which is Garfield's journey too.

But It's a straightforward retelling of familiar material. If you want something more inventive, this won't surprise you.

Mickey's Christmas Carol poster

Tokyo Godfathers2003

Like Garfield, it finds grace in unexpected places and characters who seem cynical or broken. Both argue that connection matters most when it costs something.

Satoshi Kon again, but this time a Christmas film: three homeless people find an abandoned baby and search for her parents on Christmas Eve in Tokyo. It's funny, heartbreaking, and genuinely miraculous without ever being sappy.

But The animation style is dense and sometimes frenetic. It's also quite dark—homelessness, addiction, and exploitation are real parts of the story, not softened for comfort.

Tokyo Godfathers poster

Millennium Actress2002

Both are ultimately about the stories we tell ourselves—Garfield through a cat's cynical deflection of feeling, Millennium Actress through a woman's reconfiguration of her own past. Both find the real story underneath.

Kon's masterpiece: a documentary crew interviews an aging actress and gets lost in the cinema of her life. It's structured like a puzzle-box, visually stunning, and argues that love and art are inseparable. Nothing like Garfield, which is precisely the point.

But The narrative structure is complex and demands active watching. It's not a passive experience. Some will find it pretentious; others will call it essential.

Millennium Actress poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

Garfield's Thanksgiving