Television series

Project Runway All Stars

Name: Project Runway All Stars
Released: 2012
Cast: Georgina Chapman, Isaac Mizrahi, Alyssa Milano, Zanna Roberts Rassi, Joanna Coles

Workplace drama
Light-hearted

Project Runway All Stars gathers fashion's second chances: a competition series where past contestants from the original show face off again, mentored and judged by industry heavyweights. It's Project Runway's remix—same format, sharper stakes, because these designers already know the game. For fans of the original who want to see how people have grown, or who just enjoy watching talented people sweat under pressure.

TVMaze rating

3.4

If you liked this

Project Runway2004

The original and still the definitive fashion competition. Stunning garments, real stakes, Tim Gunn's quiet wisdom, and the genuine discovery of new designers. If you haven't seen it, start here.

But Early seasons can drag in places, and some challenges feel thin. The first few episodes move slowly.

The Great British Sewing Bee2013

Competition format with warmth instead of manufactured drama. Real craftsmanship, brilliant mentorship from the judges, and contestants who genuinely root for each other. Oddly moving.

But Slower pace than Project Runway. If you're after high-octane chaos, this is cozier than you might want.

Making the Cut2020

Heidi Klum and Tim Gunn reunited, judging emerging designers with a global prize. High production values, beautiful locations, and that familiar tension between creativity and commercial viability.

But Feels slicker and less gritty than the original. Some find it more about the spectacle than the actual design work.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Project Runway All Stars

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Phantom Thread2017

The dark inverse of every 'follow your passion' competition narrative. A story about what creative perfectionism actually costs.

A haute couture dressmaker in 1950s London, obsessed with perfection and control. Daniel Day-Lewis as an artist for whom clothes are language, neurosis, and power. Hypnotic.

But Deliberately paced, deeply strange, and morally ambiguous about its protagonist. Not a comfortable film.

Face Off2011

Special effects makeup artists compete under time pressure. The technical skill is extraordinary, and watching transformations happen in real time is genuinely thrilling. Unexpectedly moving about artistry.

But If gore or body horror bothers you, many challenges will be difficult. Not everyone's cup of tea aesthetically.

Top Chef2006

The template that competition shows learned from. Culinary skills under pressure, judges who know their craft, genuine jeopardy. Seasons 5-7 are exceptional television.

But Twelve seasons in and the format calcifies. Newer seasons lean on drama over cooking.

The Apprentice2005

Corporate competition with real prize stakes. Sharp editing, genuine tension, and people revealing themselves under pressure. Early UK seasons are genuinely clever.

But The format is repetitive, and many versions (especially US) prioritize spectacle over actual business sense.

Queer Eye2018

Makeover show with real emotional intelligence. Five experts (including wardrobe) transform people's lives. Joyful, funny, and surprisingly profound about self-worth and community.

But Heavily produced and manipulative in its emotional beats. The makeovers gloss over real systemic problems with a feel-good sheen.

Work of Art: The Next Great Artist2010

Visual art under time pressure with real curators and artists as judges. Less about commerce than Project Runway, more about conceptual and technical ambition.

But Never quite lands the same way. The art world's gatekeeping can feel suffocating, and judging standards are murky.

Work of Art: The Next Great Artist poster

The September Issue2009

While All Stars shows designers competing within the system, this documentary reveals who actually decides what matters in fashion, and how.

Documentary following Vogue's editor Anna Wintour and fashion director André Leon Talley as they create a 600-page issue. Access to the actual machinery of fashion taste-making and power.

But Reverent to the point of uncritical. You must be genuinely interested in fashion hierarchy and gatekeeping; it doesn't argue against it.