Television series

A League of Their Own

Name: A League of Their Own
Genre: Comedy, Sports
Released: 2010
Cast: Jamie Redknapp, Freddie Flintoff, James Corden, Jack Whitehall, John Bishop

Other titles called A League of Their Own: the 1992 film.

Comedy
Light-hearted
Dip in and out

A League of Their Own is a rowdy sports-themed panel show where ex-footballers and comedians compete in ridiculous games and banter. James Corden hosts while Flintoff and Redknapp captain teams through challenges that have nothing to do with actual football skill. It's anarchic, silly, and built on the chemistry between its regulars—perfect if you want sports chat without the sport mattering.

TVMaze rating

3.3

Should you watch it?

Watch it if you enjoy sports talk that's mostly mucking about, the kind where ex-pros poke fun at each other and a bit of rivalry does the heavy lifting.

Skip it if you want actual match analysis or a tight format, since this is a loose, chatty hour where the games drift and the jokes lean on the captains' personalities.

What it asks of you: Light attention in hour-long slabs: brisk, cheerful and easy to dip in and out of across its twenty series, with no plot to keep track of.

Not sure? Find tonight's pick in a minute.

If you liked this

Have I Got News for You1990

The template for British panel-show chaos: sharp comedians and public figures torn apart by the hosts over the week's news. Faster, meaner, and funnier than most things on television.

But If you're not plugged into UK politics and current events, half the jokes evaporate. It rewards obsessive news-watching.

Taskmaster2015

Teams compete in beautifully absurd tasks designed to humiliate clever people in unexpected ways. Jon Richardson's deadpan scoring and the tasks' logic make every episode feel fresh and surprising.

But The first season is rough around the edges. Some tasks feel contrived or drag, especially if you're waiting for the setup to pay off.

QI2003

Stephen Fry asks seemingly simple questions with deliberately wrong answers. It's a masterclass in making trivia entertaining—smart, silly, and genuinely interested in the weird stuff nobody knows.

But Fry's hosting style doesn't work for everyone. Some find him patronising; others think the show disappeared when he left.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from A League of Their Own

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Trigger Happy TV2000

Both strip comedy down to physical chaos and the pleasure of watching composed people lose control. No elaborate setups—just smart people behaving badly and guests having no idea what's happening.

Comedians prank strangers on hidden camera with absurdist scenarios. It's pre-reality-TV, pre-internet trolling, utterly anarchic, and proves that constraint breeds creativity—all done without dialogue.

But It's dated visual comedy that relies on people not expecting cameras. If you need witty banter, you won't find it here.

Would I Lie to You?2007

Two teams of comedians and guests try to spot lies told as fact. It hinges entirely on charm and chemistry, and when it clicks, it's effortless fun with genuine surprises.

But Some versions feel forced. If the chemistry between panellists is off, there's nothing else holding it together.

8 Out of 10 Cats Does Countdown2012

Countdown meets stand-up comedy roast show. Jon Richardson and Sean Lock lead teams through word games and verbal sparring that's often filthier and faster than the original.

But It relies heavily on British comedy in-jokes and can feel like you're watching people enjoy private references you're not part of.

The Last Leg2013

News and comedy collide with disabled comedians at the centre. It's sharper and more genuinely radical than it first appears, mixing real disability representation with proper laughs.

But The political content can feel heavy-handed if you're after pure entertainment. It's trying to make a point, not just be funny.

Hypothetical2019

Comedians answer ridiculous moral dilemmas ('Would you rather fight one horse-sized duck...?'). It's pure chaos and reveals how people actually think when cornered.

But It runs on the charm of specific panellists. New versions with fresh casts haven't captured the same lightning-in-a-bottle energy.

Senna2010

Both find comedy and drama in the collision between competitive men who refuse to let each other win. The stakes are different, but the emotional engine is identical.

A documentary about Formula 1 driver Ayrton Senna told entirely through archival footage and audio. It's shaped like a tragedy, and you feel the competitive obsession in your chest even if you don't care about cars.

But It's a sports film about someone who died 25 years ago. Without knowing the sport or the man, you're watching strangers chase something invisible.

Detectorists2014

Both celebrate the pleasure of hanging out with people you're comfortable with. The games don't matter; the friendship does. Strip away the stakes and you're left with chemistry, which is everything.

Two middle-aged men hunt for metal buried in English fields. It sounds boring—it is boring, deliberately—but it's a love story about friendship, failure, and not needing anything to happen to be happy.

But Nothing happens. If you need plot momentum or tension, this will feel like a punishment. It's a show about contentment, which some people find actively annoying.