Film

The Naughty Nineties

Name: The Naughty Nineties
Genre: Comedy
Released: 1945
Cast: Bud Abbott, Lou Costello, Alan Curtis, Rita Johnson, Henry Travers

Comedy
Light-hearted

Abbott and Costello's 1945 romp on a Mississippi riverboat, where con artists have seized control from a decent captain. The duo stumble through schemes to restore order, delivering the physical comedy and rapid-fire wordplay that made them vaudeville stars. It's broad, silly, energetic fun—the kind of film that asks only that you enjoy watching two funny men be ridiculous together.

TMDb rating

3.4

If you liked this

A Night at the Opera1935

The Marx Brothers create the template for anarchic comedy on a grand set: chaos, wordplay, and a warmth under the madness. Groucho's con-man energy mirrors Abbott and Costello's scheme to outwit the villains.

But The pacing feels glacial by modern standards, and some of the jokes land softer than others. You need patience for the musical interludes.

Ride 'Em Cowboy1942

An earlier Abbott and Costello film showcasing why these two became stars: perfect timing, genuine physical comedy, and a chemistry that makes their stupidity feel like a dance. This one's tighter and faster than many of their peers.

But The film is thin on plot and doesn't pretend otherwise. If you need a story to care about, you'll spend most of the runtime waiting for the next gag.

Buck Privates1941

Their debut for Universal, still the template for why Abbott and Costello worked as a team. Slapstick, timing, and an undercurrent of warmth. The Andrews Sisters are there too, if you want something to hang the comedy on.

But It's very much a product of 1941—the comedy rhythms will feel old-fashioned, and some of the bit parts haven't aged well. The plot is negligible.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Naughty Nineties

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Hellzapoppin'1941

Both are vaudeville comedians translating their stage acts to film, using the river/stage setting as an excuse to string together comedy bits rather than build a conventional story.

The wildest Abbott and Costello contemporary: Olsen and Johnson's film is pure vaudeville bedlam, barely contained by a plot. It's meta before anyone had the word—characters aware of the camera, the sets literally falling apart, chaos as a philosophy. If you loved The Naughty Nineties, this is the same energy cranked to 11.

But It doesn't cohere. There is no narrative logic, just an endless stream of gags and interruptions. Some viewers find it exhilarating; others find it exhausting.

The Philadelphia Story1940

A masterclass in romantic comedy with impeccable timing and charm. Watching skilled comedians like Stewart and Grant reminds you what the best comedy of the era looked like when given a real screenplay and production values.

But It's not slapstick or rapid-fire—it's elegant and wordy. If you're looking for the same energy as Abbott and Costello, you won't find it here.

It Happened One Night1934

Pre-war screwball at its finest: snappy dialogue, genuine romance, and a sense that the characters are having as much fun as we are. Gable and Colbert make it look effortless, which is the highest compliment you can pay comedians.

But The pacing relies on conversation rather than spectacle. It's intimate rather than loud, which might feel slow if you're watching for slapstick.

Singin' in the Rain1952

A musical comedy where the jokes and the dancing and the charm all fuse together. Kelly and O'Connor have chemistry as strong as Abbott and Costello's, but with more resources behind them. Pure joy.

But It's not a sketch comedy. If you're drawn specifically to rapid-fire gags and physical humor, the structure might feel too measured.

The Pink Panther1963

Sellers as Inspector Clouseau proves that a single committed comedic performance can carry a film. The physical comedy is precise and creative, the accent work is brilliant, and there's real warmth underneath the chaos.

But The film around him is somewhat thin. You're watching it largely for Sellers' performance, and some of the supporting material feels like filler.

My Man Godfrey1936

Screwball comedy with real stakes underneath. Powell and Lombard have natural chemistry, the dialogue sparkles, and the film manages to be funny without being stupid—which feels like a luxury after pure slapstick.

But It moves at a talky pace and requires you to follow a plot. The comedy emerges from character and situation rather than gags, which is a very different skill.

Arsenic and Old Lace1944

Cary Grant at maximum comic energy in a murder farce where the pace never lets up. The jokes are clever, the timing is impeccable, and it's proof that comedy doesn't need to be stupid to be funny.

But It's a dark comedy about serial killing—the tone is macabre. If you want warmth and lightness, the subject matter will work against you.

Sullivan's Travels1941

Both films celebrate the power of pure entertainment and laughter to sustain people through hardship. One does it through anarchic sketches; the other through heartfelt argument.

Preston Sturges made a film about a Hollywood director who wants to make serious art but realizes comedy matters more than he thought. It's funny and moving simultaneously—a meditation on why stories like The Naughty Nineties exist. Watch it after you've felt the warmth in the Abbott and Costello.

But It's not a comedy throughout. The second half darkens significantly, and it asks you to think about comedy rather than just experience it. Some people find that shift jarring.

Sinbad the Sailor1947

Both are mid-1940s studio films where the joy of performance and the pleasure of a likable star matters more than plot logic or technical finesse. They're about watching someone talented have fun.

Douglas swashbuckles through an Technicolor fantasy with the same loose, improvisational spirit as The Naughty Nineties—no film trying too hard, just watching a skilled performer have fun with a silly setup. It's a different genre using comedy as its fuel, not its destination.

But The fantasy effects are obvious rear projection and painted sets. If you need spectacle to feel modern, you'll feel like you're watching a play. The comedy is gentler than Abbott and Costello's.