Film

The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby: Them

A fractured drama about a marriage breaking under the weight of unspeakable loss. Chastain and McAvoy orbit each other across New York, estranged and drowning. It's patient, painful, and demands your full attention—a film that trusts silence and tears over explanation. For those who want cinema that *feels* like grief.

TMDb rating3.1

If you liked this

Manchester by the Sea2016

Casey Affleck delivers a masterclass in male emotional numbness after tragedy. Like Eleanor Rigby, it moves through devastation with restraint, letting small gestures carry enormous weight. Gorgeously shot New England autumn.

But The pace is glacial and almost nothing happens. If you need plot momentum or catharsis, this will feel like being stuck in a waiting room.

Manchester by the Sea poster

Broken City2013

Another McAvoy-era character study where he plays a man fractured by circumstance. The film explores how trauma reshapes identity and connection. Quieter than you'd expect from the premise.

But It's visually flat and somewhat overwrought. The script sometimes tells rather than shows, and the resolution feels incomplete.

Broken City poster

Still Alice2014

Julianne Moore transforms a woman losing herself to illness. Like Eleanor Rigby, it's about the dissolution of identity and a marriage tested by something neither partner can fight. Unbearably intimate without ever manipulating.

But Watching someone you care about fade is genuinely difficult. This doesn't offer comfort or easy answers—it just documents the loss.

Still Alice poster

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby: Them

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Synecdoche, New York2008

Both dramatize marital dissolution through visual fragmentation and spatial disorientation. Grief doesn't explain itself; both films refuse to make it neat.

Charlie Kaufman's labyrinth about a director building a life-size replica of New York inside a warehouse while his marriage dissolves. Like Eleanor Rigby, it captures how grief fractures reality and we create art to understand loss. Devastating and formally daring.

But It's deliberately confusing, sometimes incoherent, and demands multiple viewings. The tone is aggressively bleak and Kaufman's self-pity can read as pretentious. You might finish it angry rather than moved.

Synecdoche, New York poster
More like this (8)

A Separation2011

A masterpiece about a marriage dissolving under pressure. Shot with documentary clarity, it reveals how good people can become strangers. Both leads are extraordinary, and every frame earns its place.

But It's entirely in Farsi with subtitles, and the emotional terrain is relentlessly bleak. There is no cathartic moment, only the slow recognition of incompatibility.

A Separation poster

Krisha2016

Ari Aster's debut uses non-professional actors to explore family fracture and loss. The intimacy is startling—you feel like you're watching something private and painful. Visual poetry in service of real emotion.

But The narrative is deliberately vague and the pacing deliberately slow. Some will find it pretentious or emotionally manipulative despite its restraint.

Krisha poster

Nights in Rodanthe2008

Richard Gere and Diane Lane are two people damaged by life meeting in a moment of tenderness. It doesn't shy from exploring how past grief shapes present connection. A quieter, more adult take on romance than you'd expect.

But Nicholas Sparks adaptation, so it trades in familiar emotional beats. The cinematography is aggressively soft-focus and the dialogue occasionally sentimental.

Nights in Rodanthe poster

The Son2022

Hugh Jackman plays a man consumed by his son's crisis while his new family tries to anchor him. It's about how trauma radiates outward, how we fail the people we love. Visceral and occasionally hard to watch.

But The film is relentlessly dark and offers no redemption. Some will find the plotting contrived, and the ending is deliberately ambiguous rather than resolved.

The Son poster

Moonlight2016

Three chapters of a man's life shaped by loss, desire, and the people who leave. Like Eleanor Rigby, it's about how we become strangers to ourselves. Achingly beautiful and formally inventive.

But The narrative is fragmented and poetic rather than plot-driven. If you need clear story progression or direct emotional statements, the film's obliqueness will frustrate you.

Moonlight poster

The Farewell2019

Lulu Wang explores grief, family, and cultural difference through a woman returning home for her grandmother's final months. It's warm where Eleanor Rigby is cold, but both understand how loss unmoors us. Funny, sad, unexpectedly moving.

But The tonal shifts between comedy and melancholy can feel jarring. Some viewers find the pacing uneven, and the emotional payoff arrives very quietly.

The Farewell poster

Bergman Island2021

Both use adultery and silence as languages for disconnection. Both find grandeur in the unsaid, and trust the audience to sit in ambiguity.

Mia Hansen-Løve sends a couple to Ingmar Bergman's island to write screenplays, where their relationship quietly disintegrates. It's a film about how artists process pain through their work. Minimalist, wry, and heartbreaking.

But Almost nothing happens. The characters are privileged artists navel-gazing, and if you can't find beauty in restraint and Scandinavian melancholy, it will bore you.

Bergman Island poster

Scenes from a Marriage2021

A direct lineage. Eleanor Rigby borrows Bergman's belief that marriage is a kind of slow amputation, and that cinema's job is to document the cut without flinching.

Bergman's miniseries is the skeleton key to every film about marital dissolution since. Liv Ullmann and Erland Josephson dismantle their relationship across six episodes with surgical precision. If Eleanor Rigby moved you, this is where it comes from.

But It's in Swedish, filmed on video from the seventies, and the pacing by modern standards is glacial. At six hours, it demands commitment. The dialogue is often brutal and unglamorous.

Scenes from a Marriage poster

People

Cast

Directing

Writing

Production

Recommended by

Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Silk Stocking