Film

Kill Your Idols

Name: Kill Your Idols
Genre: Documentary, Music
Released: 2004
Cast: Glenn Branca, Michael Gira, Eugene Hutz, Arto Lindsay, Lydia Lunch

Musical

A documentary tracing thirty years of New York's underground rock scene, from No Wave's ferocious authenticity through generations of musicians redefining what alternative means. It's a love letter shot in black and white, bristling with conviction. For anyone who suspects rock history happened somewhere other than MTV.

If you liked this

Dig!2004

Captures the brutal intimacy of artistic obsession through two competing LA bands. Messy, funny, tender—a portrait of creative friendship fracturing under its own weight.

But Verité documentary meandering; some find the lack of narrative structure exhausting rather than liberating.

The Decline of Western Civilization1981

Penelope Spheeris's punk-era snapshot of LA's scene before it became a commodity. Raw, unfiltered, genuinely dangerous energy frozen in time.

But Grainy 1981 footage; dated sound recording will test your patience if you need modern production values.

The Decline of Western Civilization poster

Anvil! The Story of Anvil2008

Two aging metal devotees chasing a dream that should have died decades ago. Heartbreaking and hilarious—a study in unshakeable belief.

But Heavy metal isn't your thing, and the cringe comedy occasionally overshadows genuine character study.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Kill Your Idols

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

The Virgin Suicides2000

Both use rock music not as entertainment but as a language for capturing the ineffable—desire, authenticity, the gap between who we are and who we want to become.

Sofia Coppola's dreamlike tragedy uses '70s Detroit suburbia and a garage rock score (Cocteau Twins, Heart, Air Supply reimagined) to evoke mystery and loss. Not about musicians, but saturated in music as emotional fact.

But Oblique and elliptical where documentaries are direct; some experience it as precious rather than profound.

24 Hour Party People2002

Stylish, exuberant chronicle of Factory Records and Manchester's rave scene. Feels like being inside a music obsession rather than watching one from outside.

But Frenetic editing and playful narrative tricks can feel arch if you just want the history straight.

Sid and Nancy1986

Alex Cox's punk tragedy about the Sex Pistols bassist and his doomed girlfriend. Anarchic, visually inventive, genuinely tragic beneath the chaos.

But Deliberately ugly and deliberately depressing; the punk ethos extends to viewer comfort.

Metallica: Some Kind of Monster2004

Metallica in therapy with a band coach, fracturing over ego and money. Unflinching portrait of how success corrodes the thing that made you great.

But Three and a half hours watching millionaires argue; you need tolerance for repetition and dysfunction.

Muscle Shoals2013

Southern studio as a nexus of American soul and rock. Smaller in scope than Kill Your Idols, but similarly reverent about place and community.

But More reverential than critical; doesn't interrogate its own mythology the way you might want.

Cobain: Montage of Heck2015

Brett Morgen's animated and archival biography—visually daring, deeply humane. Treats a celebrity death with actual complexity instead of myth-building.

But Heavy material about depression and suicide; the animation occasionally feels cute for subject matter that isn't.

Searching for Sugar Man2012

Mysterious South African folk singer resurfaces to discover he's a legend. A mystery box, a love story, a meditation on art and obscurity.

But Relies on plot twist; knowing it coming spoils much of the pleasure and emotional payoff.

Pussy Riot: A Punk Prayer2013

Where Kill Your Idols asks what authenticity means in a commodified scene, Pussy Riot stakes their actual freedom on the answer. The personal and political collapse into one.

Documentary about the Russian feminist punk collective's trial after a church protest. Urgent, furious, politically alive in ways most music docs aren't. Shows rock as direct action, not nostalgia.

But Explicitly political; if you need art to stay clear of activism, this will feel didactic rather than moving.

The Ballad of Little Jo1993

Both argue that authenticity is about refusing compromise, not confirming what others expect. The film's rootlessness mirrors the scene's refusal to settle.

Maggie Greenwald's western about a woman passing as a man to survive. Spare, beautiful, with the same punk ethos as No Wave—refusing easy answers about identity and belonging.

But Quiet historical fiction rather than documentary; some expect talking heads and will find this oblique.