Film

A Cock and Bull Story

Name: A Cock and Bull Story
Genre: Comedy, History
Released: 2005
Cast: Steve Coogan, Rob Brydon, Keeley Hawes, Shirley Henderson, Raymond Waring

A film about the impossibility of filming an unfilmable eighteenth-century novel, this backstage comedy has Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon playing warped, jealous versions of themselves while a costume drama disintegrates around them. Clever and self-mocking without ever seeming pleased with its own cleverness, it's best enjoyed by people who find creative chaos more entertaining than the finished product it eventually, barely, produces.

TMDb rating

6.2

If you liked this

The Trip2010

Coogan and Brydon reunite with the same director for a looser, funnier version of this exact chemistry — two competitive egos trapped together, this time over fine dining instead of a costume epic.

But It's improvised and meandering by design, so if you want tight plotting rather than bickering over restaurant menus, it will test you.

Adaptation.2002

Charlie Kaufman's own spiral about adapting an 'unfilmable' book, with Nicolas Cage playing twin screenwriters instead of Coogan playing multiple versions of himself. Same self-devouring structure, stranger and darker.

But It gets increasingly unhinged in its final act, and if you wanted restraint rather than a genre-bending swerve, it won't deliver that.

Living in Oblivion1995

A scrappy, very funny indie about the chaos of low-budget filmmaking, told through overlapping takes and constant misunderstandings — the same pleasure in watching a production quietly come apart.

But It's rougher and smaller in scale, without the costumes or starpower, so its satire lands a lot quieter.

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Lost in La Mancha2002

Both are about the near-impossibility of adapting a sprawling, digression-loving classic to film, but one plays that impossibility for laughs while the other lived it for real.

A real documentary about Terry Gilliam's doomed attempt to film Don Quixote — floods, illness, financial collapse — that turns the exact joke this film tells about adaptation into genuine heartbreak.

But There's no comic safety net; it's a document of a dream actually dying, not a send-up, so it's a much sadder watch.

Extras2005

Ricky Gervais's show about actors humiliating themselves on set for fame and money shares the same appetite for skewering vanity, with real celebrities gamely playing grotesque versions of themselves.

But The cringe comedy is relentless and can feel mean-spirited if watching people embarrass themselves isn't your idea of fun.

The Death of Stalin2017

Armando Iannucci's farce proves history can be just as riotously undignified as any costume drama, with a starry ensemble bickering their way through real events instead of an invented childhood.

But The comedy sits uncomfortably close to genuine horror, and the tonal whiplash between farce and brutality isn't for everyone.

State and Main2000no page yet

David Mamet's comedy about a film crew descending on a small town and wrecking it with their egos and compromises is the American cousin to this film's set-collapsing chaos.

But Mamet's dialogue is clipped and theatrical rather than naturalistic, which can feel mannered next to this film's looser improvisation.

Bowfinger1999

Steve Martin's broad comedy about a desperate director faking a movie around an oblivious star is dumber and louder, but mining the exact same vein of filmmaking-as-farce.

But It's played for slapstick rather than wit, so the satire here is much less cerebral and far more pratfall.

24 Hour Party People2002no page yet

Coogan's other great meta-performance, playing real-life music mogul Tony Wilson while breaking the fourth wall constantly — same director, same appetite for blurring fact and performance.

But It's rooted in Manchester music history you may not know well, and the constant narration-to-camera can feel showy rather than charming.

Slings & Arrows2003

A Canadian series about a chaotic Shakespeare festival, packed with backstage disasters and overinflated actors — a theatrical mirror to this film's cinematic mess, just gentler and warmer.

But Three short seasons and a niche theatre setting mean it's a slower, quieter build than this film's manic energy.

8½1963

Same premise, a creative person unable to make the film they're supposed to be making, but played here as existential reckoning instead of knockabout comedy.

Fellini's black-and-white masterpiece about a director paralysed mid-production, drowning in memory and ego, effectively invented the template this film is gleefully ransacking decades later.

But It's slower, dreamier and entirely serious about its own crisis — subtitled Italian arthouse rather than English farce.

This Is Spinal Tap1984

Both find their comedy in vain performers sabotaging their own project while insisting they're the real artistic force — one in rock music, one in an eighteenth-century costume drama.

The mockumentary that taught everyone how funny overconfident performers destroying a production through sheer ego can be, decades before Coogan and Brydon did it in breeches.

But It's a fake documentary about a fictional band, not actors playing versions of themselves, and its comedy is broader and dumber throughout.