Television series
Hetty Wainthropp Investigates
A retired working-class woman from Lancashire becomes an amateur detective, dragging her reluctant lodger into small-town mysteries the police won't touch. Cosy, witty, and powered by Patricia Routledge's formidable charm, it's crime drama for people who prefer kindness to cynicism—where the puzzle matters more than the darkness.
If you liked this
Midsomer Murders1998
Another British detective show that understands charm and competence matter more than grit. The mysteries are genuinely clever, the leads are warm, and it shares Hetty's faith that ordinary people can solve extraordinary things.
But It runs to seventeen series and can feel repetitive if you binge it. Some find the coziness too safe, especially if you want real stakes and consequences.
Cagney & Lacey1982
Two mismatched women working outside the system to solve cases, with real chemistry and humour beneath the procedural. It proved decades earlier that female detectives could carry a show on their intelligence and wit.
But The 1980s production values and pacing feel slower now. The tone swings between comedy and serious crime drama sometimes awkwardly.
Agatha Christie's Marple2004
Agatha Christie's Miss Marple as a sharp older woman who sees what others miss. Beautifully made, clever, and shares Hetty's delight in human nature as the real mystery beneath small-town crime.
But It's more lavish and literary than Hetty—less funny, more fastidious. Some episodes feel padded to fit the longer format.
Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from Hetty Wainthropp Investigates
The wildcard
Something you would not have found on your own.
Fargo1996
Both centre on a woman of genuine intelligence and decency in a system that underestimates her, using those qualities as an actual superpower. They believe competence and kindness are sufficient.
A pregnant police chief in Minnesota solves a crime through kindness, clear thinking, and refusing to play games. Like Hetty, she's the ordinary person who sees the truth everyone else is too cynical to look for.
But It's a Coen Brothers film—darkly violent, morally bleak, and deeply cynical about human nature. The tone is the opposite of cosy, and the body count is real. It's also considerably darker and stranger than anything Hetty encounters.
More like this (6)
A Touch of Frost1992
David Jason as a rumpled detective who bends the rules for justice. It has Hetty's warmth alongside proper police procedure, and that same satisfaction of puzzle-solving with a human heart.
But It's considerably darker and grittier. If you loved Hetty's lightness, this detective gets genuinely haunted by his cases.
Pie in the Sky1994
A detective who runs a restaurant while solving crimes—amateur investigation meets eccentric charm. The tone is wry and the mysteries secondary to character, much like Hetty's approach.
But The cooking subplot can feel forced. It's very of its time and doesn't take itself seriously enough for some viewers.
Agatha Christie Poirot1989
Meticulous, clever whodunits with a detective who loves his own deductions. Like Hetty, Poirot solves cases others have dismissed, and David Suchet brings genuine warmth to the character.
But It's more formal and ornate. If you want the scrappy DIY energy of Hetty's investigations, this is too polished and procedural.
The Avengers1961
Two mismatched partners solving crimes with style and wit. It's the DNA of all intelligent spy-crime comedy that followed; lighter and more playful than Hetty but operating on similar principles of charm over realism.
But The early episodes are rough and campy in ways that haven't aged well. The later, glossier episodes lose some of what made it special.
Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries2012
A glamorous 1920s detective in Melbourne solves cases with flair and feminism. Like Hetty, she's a woman whose intelligence and determination matter more than her circumstances—just with better hats.
But It's significantly sexier and more fashionable than Hetty. The tone is breezier, sometimes sacrificing character depth for style.
Lovejoy1986
An antiques dealer solves mysteries in the English countryside with charm and improvisation. Shares Hetty's gift for spotting what others miss and her delight in outsmarting both criminals and bureaucrats.
But It's dated and uneven in quality. Some episodes feel like excuses to feature antiques rather than tell a story.
