Film

A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving

Name: A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving
Genre: Animation, Comedy, Family, TV Movie
Released: 1973
Cast: Todd Barbee, Robin Kohn, Stephen Shea, Hilary Momberger-Powers, Christopher DeFaria

Comedy
Light-hearted

A 25-minute Peanuts special where Charlie Brown attempts to host Thanksgiving dinner for the gang, armed with almost no cooking skills and a lot of good intentions. It's warmly funny without being saccharine, genuinely touching without sentiment feeling forced, and structured like a perfect little play—conflict, chaos, resolution, grace. For anyone who loves the Peanuts comic strip, or anyone who wants to remember what it felt like when TV specials felt like real events.

TMDb rating

3.7

If you liked this

It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown1966

The template Peanuts special: Linus's faith, Sally's greed, Snoopy's absurdist flights, Charlie Brown's existential dread—all the emotional notes in 25 minutes. The writing is sharp enough to make you laugh and think at once.

But If you've never connected with Peanuts, this won't convert you. It moves at a deliberately contemplative pace that can feel slow if you're not already invested.

It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown poster

A Charlie Brown Christmas1965

The other essential Peanuts special, and in some ways even better: a meditation on commercialism and meaning dressed as a children's show. Genuinely moving, funny, and the jazz score is perfect.

But The special's sadness is real, not sugar-coated. If you want pure comfort, this leans melancholic in ways that might dampen the mood.

Garfield's Thanksgiving1989

Similar structure and length, same era of TV special craftsmanship. Gentler and broader in humor, with Garfield's lazy schemes replacing Charlie Brown's anxious sincerity—but the heart is genuine.

But Less sharp writing than Peanuts. If you're watching for wit, you'll find warmth instead, which isn't everyone's thing.

Not sure tonight? Get a pick in a minute, starting from A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving

The wildcard

Something you would not have found on your own.

Paddington 22017

Both begin with a character trying to perform an adult ritual perfectly (cooking, Christmas gift-giving) and both end with a realization that showing up and trying matters more than technical success. Both are about the grace of being loved anyway.

A feature film that does what Charlie Brown Thanksgiving does on a grand scale: uses a holiday/ritual framework to explore kindness, competence, and what it means to be genuinely accepted. Funny for adults, moving for children, technically brilliant.

But It's 103 minutes, not 25—a bigger time commitment. Also British in sensibility, which reads sentimental to some viewers rather than earned.

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer1964

Stop-motion holiday special that shares the Peanuts special DNA: earnest, visually distinctive, weirdly dark in places, structured like a real story rather than a sketch show.

But The stop-motion can look dated or stiff if you've only seen modern CGI. Some of the logic doesn't hold up to scrutiny.

The Thanksgiving That Almost Wasn't1972

A live-action sitcom pilot about a family preparing Thanksgiving, capturing the same pre-microwave chaos and good-natured scrambling that makes Charlie Brown's dinner attempt endearing.

But It's obscure for a reason—competent but slight, lacking the Peanuts special's satirical edge or emotional depth.

The Thanksgiving That Almost Wasn't poster

Over the Garden Wall2014

A miniseries that captures what made the Peanuts specials work: hand-drawn animation, folk-song score, genuine darkness mixed with humor, a complete story arc in minimal time. Gorgeous and eerie.

But It's darker than Charlie Brown—genuinely unsettling at times. If you want pure comfort, this goes places that might unsettle instead of soothe.

Moonlight Serenade2009

A feature-length Peanuts film made overseas years after the original specials stopped. More ambitious scope, but tries to capture the same emotional tone and satirical humor about adulthood seen through kids' eyes.

But Made without the original creative team, it can feel like an imitation rather than continuation. Not bad, but noticeably secondary to the classics.