Pajama Andrew

Pajama Andrew is the version of Andrew Glouberman that existed before puberty turned everything upside down — cheerful, uncomplicated, still delighted by pancakes and cartoons, wandering into scenes as a wistful reminder of who Andrew used to be. He doesn't scheme or lust; he just wants things to be simple again, the way they were.

The joke is in the contrast: John Mulaney's same amiable voice, but stripped of all the anxious, horned-up static that defines regular Andrew. Pajama Andrew is what innocence sounds like next to chaos, and the show uses him sparingly enough that every appearance lands as both funny and a little sad.