Nick Godejohn

Nick meets Gypsy through an online Christian dating site, and the introduction alone tells you he is starved for connection — awkward, earnest, prone to strange enthusiasms about knives and horror movies. He lives with his mother, works retail, and falls for Gypsy's messages with a speed that reads as loneliness rather than calculation.

Calum Worthy plays Nick's oddness without condescension, letting his tics and blurted honesty feel like real social exhaustion rather than a writer's shorthand for 'creepy.' The performance keeps you uncertain whether to laugh at him, worry for him, or worry about what he might do — and that uncertainty is exactly the point.