Judge

The Judge presides over Big Mouth's recurring courtroom digressions, a robed arbiter who hears absurd cases about grudges, petty resentments, and the statute of limitations on old wounds. She listens to the show's characters plead their grievances with theatrical patience, ready to rule with a gavel and a knowing smirk.

The bit only works because Maya Rudolph plays it completely straight, giving these interludes a mock gravity that makes the show's silliest impulses land as genuine wisdom. She turns a recurring gag into something like a Greek chorus, dispensing emotional common sense while never breaking the joke.